cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

account closure

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: account closure

Maybe no one has but everyone keeps putting emphasis on everyone wanting 1% utility, period. It is really not a big deal, it's about personal preference.
Message 101 of 106
taxi818
Super Contributor

Re: account closure

For me I'm always under 15%. Currently at 10. But it's not a big deal one way or the other. I'm not about to micro manage something like that. But I also make a habit not to overspend. Smiley Happy
Message 102 of 106
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: account closure

Ive managed to stay under 6% utilization total despite having at least one card report over 50% recently.
Message 103 of 106
Marcos8
Established Contributor

Re: account closure

I have 4 cards and I let each one of them report a balance every month. My total UTL is about 4-6%.  I want my creditors to see my normal spending habits and my normal payment habits and the reality is sometimes I don't PIF every time. I may carry a balance and take a few months to pay it off. I put reminders in my phone to alert me of upcoming CLis and then for a month or two I get my profile nice and spiffy with one or maybe two accounts reporting zero balances, one of which is usually the card I'm trying to cli at the time. After the CLI I go back to normal spend. If I micro managed each account and then needed some float I don't want that to all of a sudden look peculiar to my creditors and spook them. 

Message 104 of 106
Stralem
Established Contributor

Re: account closure

70~90%% util for a year now (long story, don't wanna get into it), and I haven't heard a peep from any of these companies.

 

Just recently paid off three, however, and I haven't even been balance chased.

 

incomprehensible, man.

 

I want them to take adverse action.

 

I. want. to be. nailed.

 

Why won't they?

 

Am I not bad enough?

 

Why doesn't Chase pay attention to me? Smiley Sad

I Have Way Too Many of These.

American Express - No CLI or Appreciation Gift in 7 Years

Citibank - Handing Out Credit Limits Like Candy

Chase - Surprisingly, Still Tolerating My Credit-Chasing Ways

Bank of America - My Newest Bae.

Everyone Else.
Message 105 of 106
Ghoshida
Valued Contributor

Re: account closure


@Stralem wrote:

70~90%% util for a year now (long story, don't wanna get into it), and I haven't heard a peep from any of these companies.

 

Just recently paid off three, however, and I haven't even been balance chased.

 

incomprehensible, man.

 

I want them to take adverse action.

 

I. want. to be. nailed.

 

Why won't they?

 

Am I not bad enough?

 

Why doesn't Chase pay attention to me? Smiley Sad


I don't see your income listed here and your history with Chase, but maybe they are the reasons? Smiley Happy

 

I'm sure by now people here realize that utilization is not the sole metric, not even the credit report; lenders also look at income, current employer, other obligations etc.

 

I hear Barclays horror stories on these boards and I even panicked for a while thinking Barclays will balance chase me the moment I paid down their 80-90% balance on the $3k SMMC that I had been carrying over 4-5 months. I used to pay down 3-400 and then charge it back again, groceries and gas, 0% APR. No AA once I paid it down, instead, received a $3k auto CLI in the immediate statement. Discover often offers SP and auto CLIs with high enough balances, no problem. My friend got an auto CLI on his Chase Freedom from $5.5 to $10k with a $4k balance during 0% APR; it's his go-to card. I'm sure we'll come across similar stories here; not only lenders don't go around doing AA like crazy, sometimes they reward heavy usage and carrying balances.

 

Now when I was at 80% util with Barclays, their CL was less than 10% of my income, and was a small number to start with. The bank knew I could pay it off over time, and saw me making regular payments, even if the balance was not going down. Had that CL been $20k, with my income, the bank would have thought twice and most likely closed the card or taken some other AA. On the other extreme, if the CL was low, and I was purchasing as well as paying many times my income, Barclays would have thought I was MSing and then taken AA, or if I was lucky, done some kind of FR (dunno if it happens with them). Right now, my total CL is more than double my annual individual salary. Even if I let 30% post (which is considered safe territory) across the board, I'm playing with fire.

 

Anyway, I guess the point is that one man's 50% is another man's, well, no big deal. Just like most other things in credit, you need to consider the full picture. Banks don't mind carrying a balance; as long as the balance is something that the bank thinks you'll be able to pay off. On some cards, it may be 90%, on some others, even 40% may be a big deal. 

Message 106 of 106
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.