Curious if anyone has dealt with this - I opened three dispute at the beginning of this week for medical collections. Two were removed the day I initiated the dispute. The third largest was updated as verified early today. Then I received an email that the dispute was opened again. I did not file a request to reopen the dispute. Has anyone had a dispute closed and then re-opened when disputing online through Experian?
AU: 
Dispute opened 1/19 for all three disputes. 2 were removed on 1/19, nearly immediately (within two hours). The third was "verified as accurate" and updated 1/24. Then later that same day, I received a new alert that an account dispute was opened (I did not initiate a new dispute, it just appeared with the original dispute date of 1/19).
The mystery continues... OK, without receiving another notification that the dispute was removed, I woke up this morning to all three disputes being gone from my Experian and by score went up by 52 points. I am ecstatic, but also confused because the other two disputes I received a notice they were removed before it updated the next day to reflect that. I have had an insane streak of luck the past couple of days, thank you lunar near year !(?)
Yes, I have already paid all of the debt through the OC (ER). Is that what you mean by "provider" (i.e. not the CA)?