cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Is 3 credit cards on new file too many?

tag
RobynJ
Established Contributor

Is 3 credit cards on new file too many?

I just started to build my file again late in life. I started fresh as it's been years since I've had any type of credit. I started with rentreporters.com and that gave me a 3year 8 month aaoa and a 24 month of perfect pay history. I found out that the Fico 8 as of yet (and earlier models) do not count the pay history towards a score but it does account for aaoa. The new models Fico 9,10 and VS 3.0-4.0 do score for the rental agreement. My question is I signed up for 3 secured cards 1-Discover it $300cl 2-Capital One Platnum $301cl and 3-Open Sky CC $$200cl. Discover gave me 2HP on EX and TU,  Capital One gave me a HP on all three, and OpenSky only did a soft pull. I did this all within 2 months. Everything but Capital One has been reporting to all 3 and they will hit before the 28th this month. I started with a 0 CS with no derog and no inquiries until what I just stated. My Vantage scores are 672 both TU and EQ and my Fico 9 was a 742 and yet I'm still a 0 on Fico 8. Since the rental agreement does not report to EXP I have a 0 score on all models. What do you think my FICO 8 will be in 6 months of opening accounts and my Utl <9% on all cards. Also should I open a SSL now with my CU and take any hits immediately? Note if I did this I would pay all but 9% of the SSL within 5 days of opening. Opinions, Thoughts, Strategies??

> > > > > > > > >

Starting Score:
0

Current Score:
My highest 818

Goal Score:
850


Take the myFICO Fitness Challenge



/
Message 1 of 13
12 REPLIES 12
SouthJamaica
Mega Contributor

Re: Is 3 credit cards on new file too many?


@RobynJ wrote:

I just started to build my file again late in life. I started fresh as it's been years since I've had any type of credit. I started with rentreporters.com and that gave me a 3year 8 month aaoa and a 24 month of perfect pay history. I found out that the Fico 8 as of yet (and earlier models) do not count the pay history towards a score but it does account for aaoa. The new models Fico 9,10 and VS 3.0-4.0 do score for the rental agreement. My question is I signed up for 3 secured cards 1-Discover it $300cl 2-Capital One Platnum $301cl and 3-Open Sky CC $$200cl. Discover gave me 2HP on EX and TU,  Capital One gave me a HP on all three, and OpenSky only did a soft pull. I did this all within 2 months. Everything but Capital One has been reporting to all 3 and they will hit before the 28th this month. I started with a 0 CS with no derog and no inquiries until what I just stated. My VS scores are 672 both TU and EQ and my Fico 9 was a 742. The rent reporters don't report to EXP so I don't have a score yet on it. What do you think my FICO 8 will be in 6 months of opening accounts and my CU <9% on all cards. Also should I open a SSL now with my CU and take any hits immediately? Also if I did I would pay all but 9% of the SSL within 5 days of opening. Opinions, Thoughts, Strategies??


I think you should just wait and see before adding anything to the mix.


Total revolving limits 569520 (505320 reporting) FICO 8: EQ 689 TU 684 EX 685




Message 2 of 13
moto4man
Regular Contributor

Re: Is 3 credit cards on new file too many?

Is a secured LOC an option?  That would be the one thing over time that could possibly give you the boost and fatten things up a bit over the 6 month haul.  I say possibly, because as you know... I'm super new to the game as well.  I've got a history, but it's been all bad.  Not as bad as I originally had thought, but bad none the less.  And an installment loan might be the one thing that your file needs to move forward.  Again, I'm looking at a semi long haul for your situation.  6 months to a year. 

 

Definitly wait/check with the greater minds here, but that's what sticks out.   I know I've went off the beaten path in relation to your post.  But cosidering you've already gotten those 3 cards, I'm just doing a little assumption based commenting here. 

Starting Score: 547EX
Current Score: 694EX 689EQ 696TU
Goal Score: 750


Take the myFICO Fitness Challenge
Message 3 of 13
RobynJ
Established Contributor

Re: Is 3 credit cards on new file too many?

@SouthJamaica  Thank you, may I ask how long should I garden for? My goal is in 3 years to buy a house. 

 

@moto4man  Yes it may take a little longer but as long as you're heading in the right direction that's what matters. Like I have read in here so many times, slow and steady wins the race. As for the LOC I have never looked into one tbh. How do they work?

> > > > > > > > >

Starting Score:
0

Current Score:
My highest 818

Goal Score:
850


Take the myFICO Fitness Challenge



/
Message 4 of 13
SouthJamaica
Mega Contributor

Re: Is 3 credit cards on new file too many?


@RobynJ wrote:

@SouthJamaica  Thank you, may I ask how long should I garden for? My goal is in 3 years to buy a house. 

 

@moto4man  Yes it may take a little longer but as long as you're heading in the right direction that's what matters. Like I have read in here so many times, slow and steady wins the race. 


I wouldn't suggest a specific time period. I think you should just manage your accounts well for the next couple of months, see what your scores are after they report, and play it by ear. Let the Discover card or Capital One card report a very small balance ($20 or so) before paying it off, while the other 2 cards report zero balances.

 

If your scores are over 700, then I would suggest applying for an unsecured card of your choosing.  You may want to come back to the forum, tell us what  your scores are then and what you're looking for in a credit card, and you'll get lots of suggestions.


Total revolving limits 569520 (505320 reporting) FICO 8: EQ 689 TU 684 EX 685




Message 5 of 13
RobynJ
Established Contributor

Re: Is 3 credit cards on new file too many?

@SouthJamaica 

As a wise man once told me, I am going gardening :-)

> > > > > > > > >

Starting Score:
0

Current Score:
My highest 818

Goal Score:
850


Take the myFICO Fitness Challenge



/
Message 6 of 13
HeavenOhio
Senior Contributor

Re: Is 3 credit cards on new file too many?

@RobynJ, the "default" answer would be to garden simply because of the three new accounts. I'd suggest waiting until one or all of your cards is a year old. At that point, there should be some nice options opening up. The good news, of course, is that there's nothing bad happening on your profile. All you need is a little time.

Message 7 of 13
RobynJ
Established Contributor

Re: Is 3 credit cards on new file too many?

@HeavenOhio 

 

Thank you, I appreciate the advise. 

UPDATE: I hated asking a relative at my age to help me out but at this point it was for the best IMHO. I was added to his AMEX Blue with a $30k CL and a $500 balance. He has had it for over 14 years and never runs it up. I made sure the card would go to him and he can hold it. I don't want the actual card just the age of account to help my file out. 0589E49C-D641-4D9C-8B83-27D4D7E1CA90.jpeg

 

 

> > > > > > > > >

Starting Score:
0

Current Score:
My highest 818

Goal Score:
850


Take the myFICO Fitness Challenge



/
Message 8 of 13
NoHardLimits
Established Contributor

Re: Is 3 credit cards on new file too many?


@RobynJ wrote:

UPDATE: I hated asking a relative at my age to help me out but at this point it was for the best IMHO. I was added to his AMEX Blue with a $30k CL and a $500 balance. He has had it for over 14 years and never runs it up. I made sure the card would go to him and he can hold it. I don't want the actual card just the age of account to help my file out. 0589E49C-D641-4D9C-8B83-27D4D7E1CA90.jpeg

 

 


Unfortunately, American Express is a credit card issuer which will not grant authorized users the same account opening date as the primary cardholder.  The "date opened" will show up on your credit report with the date you were added to the account.  You will not benefit from the 14 years of age, though the $30k credit limit may be of some help.

April 2025 Scorecard: Clean, Thick, Mature, New Revolver
FICO8:
FICO9:
VantageScore3:
Inquiries (n/12, n/24):
AAoA: 11 yrs | AoORA: 37 yrs | AoYRA: less than 1 yr | New Accounts: 1/6, 2/12, 2/24 | Util: 1% | DTI: 1%
Message 9 of 13
RobynJ
Established Contributor

Re: Is 3 credit cards on new file too many?

@NoHardLimits 

Thank you;

Are there any that do? I've read threads on here before saying that they do but after your post I now see back in 2015 that was changed   

> > > > > > > > >

Starting Score:
0

Current Score:
My highest 818

Goal Score:
850


Take the myFICO Fitness Challenge



/
Message 10 of 13
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.