cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Laughing at credit tracker

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Laughing at credit tracker

Just looking at capital ones credit tracker since i was bored and thought I would share the comedy it provided tonight. First off, my FICO scores are over 700. Credit tracker says I have a score of 639. Eliminating balances, lowering balances, maintaining payments for 24 months, or having a tax lien will keep my score the same. But the best part is that a foreclosure will raise my score 16 points. Child support and wage garnishment will raise it 6.

I want the biggest boost in score I can get, so I think I will go with the foreclosure option. LOL
Message 1 of 7
6 REPLIES 6
Credit_hawk
Established Contributor

Re: Laughing at credit tracker

Yeah, Cap One's Credit Tracker is pretty bad. It also low balls my scores horribly. I am in the mid 700s and it has me at an 675 or something. Yet when I first used it I was at a 695 with a FICO at 700. It is so wierd. I think it weighs heavily any balance at all on a credit card. I keep mine at 3% but when it was at 0% thats when my scores were the best. The only thing its good for is inquiry alerts. They come the next day after hard pulls.

FICO- Experian: 797, TransUnion: 781, Equifax: 804 (Updated Monthly)
Message 2 of 7
fedxboy
Established Contributor

Re: Laughing at credit tracker

I don't know why CapOne's credit tracker is way off for you both as I just checked mine and it has me at

 

 

Credit Score 
Next update available: 10/12/2015
759
My Credit Standing: Good
 
 
Which is relatively where all my other FICOS are......


(7/23/16) AMEX FICO EX 728, (6/20/16) Discover FICO TU 747, (7/24/16) Barclays FICO 750 (TC Lines $400+K) AAoA= 4.3 yrs
Message 3 of 7
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Laughing at credit tracker

Ha mine says 579!!! Hasnt left the 500s ever
Message 4 of 7
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Laughing at credit tracker

About 2 months ago, it decided I could boost my score by not making my car payments. Since I commute an hour each way for work, I figured I'd take a pass on that one. 😅 This month it seemed pretty stable though. Kinda can't wait to see what it says next month!

Message 5 of 7
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Laughing at credit tracker


@fedxboy wrote:

I don't know why CapOne's credit tracker is way off for you both as I just checked mine and it has me at

 

 

Credit Score 
Next update available: 10/12/2015
759
My Credit Standing: Good
 
 
Which is relatively where all my other FICOS are......

It's off because it's a Fako score, and is notoriously known for being unreliable as a true indicator of the FICO score. It said that a foreclosure would boost my score if that gives you any indication of how good it is. Just like CK or any other Fako score provider, it should be ignored for all intents and purposes. They call it an "educational score", but the only education you get from it is when you learn that it should be disregarded. It is merely a coincidence that yours match up, as that is not the norm.

Message 6 of 7
takeshi74
Senior Contributor

Re: Laughing at credit tracker


@Anonymous wrote:
First off, my FICO scores are over 700. Credit tracker says I have a score of 639.

You cannot use a score generated by one model to determine the score generated by a different model -- even if both models are FICO's.  Models (including the various FICO's -- see also the Understanding FICO Scoring subforum and its stickies) vary in how their algorithms weigh the different factors.  Further, not all models are on the same scoring scales.  You always need to consider both the specific scoring model and the CRA.

 

CO's Credit Tracker uses the TransUnion New Account model which is not used by creditors.  Capital One's site has this information.

http://www.capitalone.com/credit-cards/benefits/credit-tracker/

Your Credit Tracker score is calculated based on the TransUnion New Account Model.
This informational/educational score is not used for credit or lending decisions.

Always consider the relevance of a given score.  If it's not used for credit or lending decisions then the score doesn't really have any relevance.  You can try to use the trending (I advise being careful even with this as different models can trend differently) of the score as a rough guide of the shape of your credit but, again, you cannot use it to determine your score with any other scoring model.

 


@Anonymous wrote:
Eliminating balances, lowering balances, maintaining payments for 24 months, or having a tax lien will keep my score the same. But the best part is that a foreclosure will raise my score 16 points. Child support and wage garnishment will raise it 6.

Most simulators tend to be unreliable.  Further, no one simulator can simulate every model out there.  Instead of fixating on the numbers. learn about the standard scoring and risk factors and use the knowledge to assess your own reports.  Any score is generated based on the data in a report.  Good reports will lead to good scores.

 


@fedxboy wrote:

I don't know why CapOne's credit tracker is way off for you both as I just checked mine and it has me at

Which is relatively where all my other FICOS are.....


As with any topic, coincidental and causal are two entirely different things.  Different scoring models can coincidentally produce similar or even the same numbers for specific situations but that does not mean that there is a causal relationship between the two.

 

Again, if you want to know what your score is with specific model and CRA then pull it.  Don't even assume that all FICO's are the same.  Otherwise, you're likely to end up disapppointed when you're referring to a different model than what a creditor pulls for you and there's a discrepancy in the numbers.

Message 7 of 7
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.