No credit card required
Browse credit cards from a variety of issuers to see if there's a better card for you.
Hi All,
I have subscribed to USAA's CMS, and have noticed that while I can get updated reports daily, my PLUS scores have only updated on a monthly basis. Is this typical, or are the scores supposed to update daily as well? I ask because there is now lower utilization reporting for the past week, but no change in scores. And yes, I know they're FAKO scores, but it's nice to see any type of positive change...
Mine hardly change ever. For the first 4 months or so that I had USAA, they didn't change at all. I thought it was a glitch or something.
A simple change in utilization may not affect the score unless it is an amount or percentage that is a part of their formula to determine the FAKO score. I have USAA and pull about 3-4 times a month. My utilization has been at 20% + for the last several months. I have been paying down debt and it is slowly dropping but the scores remained the same. I pulled today and my reported utilization dropped to 19%. My scores increased by 10-15 points. So I am guessing that for USAA Plus scores one of the markers may be less than 20%. This is just based on my own recent experience (23% to 22% to 21% to 20% resulted in no score change.) On the other hand maybe an account reaching a certain age or the temperature in Moscow Idaho being above average for the day changed the score. It's FAKO in the end and I'm not going to waste a lot of time deciphering it.
I use USAA monitoring for the account information and to see when creditors have updated. It's also good about alerts when things happen such as inquiries or new accounts reporting. I have an old collection on two of my reports that FICO says is hurting where it appears (On EQ not on TU) but USAA monitoring says "You have no negative information - this is a positive factor, even when it is clearly visible on my EQ and EX report summary.
@Anonymous wrote:A simple change in utilization may not affect the score unless it is an amount or percentage that is a part of their formula to determine the FAKO score. I have USAA and pull about 3-4 times a month. My utilization has been at 20% + for the last several months. I have been paying down debt and it is slowly dropping but the scores remained the same. I pulled today and my reported utilization dropped to 19%. My scores increased by 10-15 points. So I am guessing that for USAA Plus scores one of the markers may be less than 20%. This is just based on my own recent experience (23% to 22% to 21% to 20% resulted in no score change.) On the other hand maybe an account reaching a certain age or the temperature in Moscow Idaho being above average for the day changed the score. It's FAKO in the end and I'm not going to waste a lot of time deciphering it.
I use USAA monitoring for the account information and to see when creditors have updated. It's also good about alerts when things happen such as inquiries or new accounts reporting. I have an old collection on two of my reports that FICO says is hurting where it appears (On EQ not on TU) but USAA monitoring says "You have no negative information - this is a positive factor, even when it is clearly visible on my EQ and EX report summary.
Thanks, Holding.
This actually does make sense. I am SLOWLY paying down utilization right now, and I probably haven't decreased it enough to trigger a score change.
FWIW, my USAA FAKOs have moved up and down by a few points here and there at least monthly, but EQ is the one that baffles me the most. You can see my FICO in my siggy line, but my USAA numbers look like this:
9/2011: EX - 619 EQ - 571 TU - 543
4/2012: EX - 671 EQ - 570 TU - 638
Pretty much the same stuff has come off of all 3 as far as baddies go. Utilization has updated properly across all 3. I just don't get why EX and TU show steady increases (much like my true EQ FICO) while the EQ FAKO sits and stews at the same level. Mind-boggling, really, even when remembering that they are fake.
Mine has changed quite a bit over the last 2 months since subscribing, but YMMV
I think FICO the util rate will score different in those ranges: (according to fico app)
0-9%
10-19%
20-29%
30-39%
etc
also, the total amount you owned will score different in those ranges:
0~500$
500~999$
1k~4999$
5k~9999$
10k~20K
20k+
If you change the range of your util and amount owned the score will definitely change.
If we could only go by those PLUS scores from USAA, they have us in the 750 ballpark and have not ever moved. When we bought the real FICO® score, we were crestfallen -- what a difference. Its the reports we use USAA CMS for, the scores truly are worthless.
@Anonymous wrote:If we could only go by those PLUS scores from USAA, they have us in the 750 ballpark and have not ever moved. When we bought the real FICO® score, we were crestfallen -- what a difference. Its the reports we use USAA CMS for, the scores truly are worthless.
Wouldn't that be great?!? My PLUS scores are 738/729/738 - I'd take those any day...
I was going to post this question, glad I did a search. My scores only updated for the the first week (in Jan). Since then, no change. My util has gone down a bit, but 3 CA's came off and 2 TL's gone (1 may come back so monitoring closely). I would think I should see some sort of change in 3 months. But basically just using the service to monitor my reports for changes. Will pull FICO at then end of this month.