cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

PSECU Epic Fail :(

tag
AverageJoesCredit
Legendary Contributor

PSECU Epic Fail :(

It looks like my time in this here credit world is almost, if not truely up. I keep on racking up epic fail after epic fail and i may need to step away from credit for awhile to somehow concentrate and tackling my rising debt. Ive obviously hit the wall on what lenders will lend me or approve me. Scores are meaningless without the income to back them up. Looking back i probably have like 6-10 straight hps with all rejections. Lol, this post wasnt meant to be a rant or an Avengers End Game but well just helps my mental to put it out there.

Anyhow, recently applied for membership here with PSECU and eventually approved albeit a hp on Ex. Decided to try for a CC, and even after uploading 2 paystubs, dl, and last two w2's, rejected as usual.

How bad am i? Decided to give Penfed one last try, rejoined, though was a bit more crazy to join especially with verification. Was approved for membership, another Eq pull. What the heck right, tried for Gold cc, yup, another rejectionSmiley Wink.

At least when I tried for Pl with Navy, they at least countered my proposed loan amount. Give them luv for that but i didnt want 2 pl reporting so took another useless hp to EQ. i get it for the most part. My income sucks, snd they dont like the ratio. I just wish a credit score meant something. That paying on time meant something. It is what it is. Credit game is for those with money and i understand that. Its life. Appreciate those who have read this and my many post , good or bad. Ive never professed to be perfect or an expert but i hope at least my failures could help someone, especially those lower income people. Ive learned many lessons in my 4 year rebuild journey i just hope i can really start to apply them. Thanks for reading ,AJC🧔
Message 1 of 15
14 REPLIES 14
DaveInAZ
Senior Contributor

Re: PSECU Epic Fail :(

Did I miss a flavor of the month? Why would you try for a Pennsylvania State Employees credit union? I had to googlee PSECU. it looks like you can join with a $20 donation to the state parks society, but their banking accounts and CCs look pretty meh to me.

 

And Penfed is well documented for saying 'nothing for you' to modest income folks. I do think that is strange as they claim to target active and retired military, and those two groups aren't exactly known for sky high pay grades. And lenders should consider income in relation to where they live - an income that would have you living in a parked car in the S.F. Bay area would have you living modestly well in many other parts of the country. My mortgage is less than $500/mo. and in rural southern Arizona that gets me a comfortable home with mountain views on 10 acres, in the bay area I couldn't rent a garage to park my car for that. 

Message 2 of 15
credit_endurance
Valued Contributor

Re: PSECU Epic Fail :(

Sorry to hear about the denials AJC. Its always "huge' let down to being denied. We sometimes go for other ill advised options just to cushion the blow of the denial. This credit game sometimes isn't very fair at all. Everyone won't be that blessed with the income to attract certain lenders. I feel you brother about scores not being the true secret to sucess. I still have a couple of 'dirty" reports in my possesion trying wait out the hopefully eventual fall off but, it's certainly not an easy process. We just have to keep cooling our heels aka (gardening stints), and plugging along until better options swing our way. All the best my friend. Smiley Wink

Starting FICO08 Scores 2016 All in the mid 500’s
Current FICO08 Scores SEP 2023 (TU 834) (EQ 831 (EXP 831)

“The credit is no longer bruised, it has endured the test of time” (formally know as bruisedcredit)

Message 3 of 15
AverageJoesCredit
Legendary Contributor

Re: PSECU Epic Fail :(

Thanks @credit_endurance , ill always be a pm awaySmiley Wink
Message 4 of 15
pinkandgrey
Senior Contributor

Re: PSECU Epic Fail :(

That’s okay, AJC. I think all (or at least most) of us have had those weird moments where we get denied and then throw all caution to the wind in an attempt to secure an approval. I certainly did lol

 

But that’s the past. Almost 6 months in the garden for me. *insert small, unenthusiastic “yay”* 

Discover It: 26.5k
Fidelity Visa: 21.5k
Amex Cash Magnet: 20k
Apple Card: 9k
Message 5 of 15
SouthJamaica
Mega Contributor

Re: PSECU Epic Fail :(


@AverageJoesCredit wrote:
It looks like my time in this here credit world is almost, if not truely up. I keep on racking up epic fail after epic fail and i may need to step away from credit for awhile to somehow concentrate and tackling my rising debt. Ive obviously hit the wall on what lenders will lend me or approve me. Scores are meaningless without the income to back them up. Looking back i probably have like 6-10 straight hps with all rejections. Lol, this post wasnt meant to be a rant or an Avengers End Game but well just helps my mental to put it out there.

Anyhow, recently applied for membership here with PSECU and eventually approved albeit a hp on Ex. Decided to try for a CC, and even after uploading 2 paystubs, dl, and last two w2's, rejected as usual.

How bad am i? Decided to give Penfed one last try, rejoined, though was a bit more crazy to join especially with verification. Was approved for membership, another Eq pull. What the heck right, tried for Gold cc, yup, another rejectionSmiley Wink.

At least when I tried for Pl with Navy, they at least countered my proposed loan amount. Give them luv for that but i didnt want 2 pl reporting so took another useless hp to EQ. i get it for the most part. My income sucks, snd they dont like the ratio. I just wish a credit score meant something. That paying on time meant something. It is what it is. Credit game is for those with money and i understand that. Its life. Appreciate those who have read this and my many post , good or bad. Ive never professed to be perfect or an expert but i hope at least my failures could help someone, especially those lower income people. Ive learned many lessons in my 4 year rebuild journey i just hope i can really start to apply them. Thanks for reading ,AJC🧔

Wherever we stand in the money game, the things we learn and share here are (a) interesting and (b) useful. The problem with being here is that some of us -- and I put myself at or near the top of the list -- get caught up in applying for stuff we shouldn't be applying for. The potential thrill of an approval works against our rationality. We drink the MyFICO Forum koolaid.

 

You are truly one of the kindest and most generous people on this forum. Your warmth and humor have made you many friends here, and your communication abilities have made you a leader of the social aspect of the forum, so it is only natural for you to sometimes take a flyer on an application your gray matter tells you is not a good bet, so that you can report back on it.

 

I know you will find the right way to work it out in your mind, how you should handle this forum going forward.

 

Whatever you decide, much respect.


Total revolving limits 569520 (505320 reporting) FICO 8: EQ 689 TU 684 EX 673




Message 6 of 15
credit_endurance
Valued Contributor

Re: PSECU Epic Fail :(

I totally echo the sentiments expressed by SouthJamaica. You are a true asset to this forum community. We share our experiences both the good and bad and support the choices (each) is us make in the credit world. There will certainly be better days ahead.
Starting FICO08 Scores 2016 All in the mid 500’s
Current FICO08 Scores SEP 2023 (TU 834) (EQ 831 (EXP 831)

“The credit is no longer bruised, it has endured the test of time” (formally know as bruisedcredit)

Message 7 of 15
pizza1
Community Leader
Super Contributor

Re: PSECU Epic Fail :(

aw man...sorry AJCSmiley Sad

It may not be your income, but your DTIR thats getting these denials. Get that debt load down, and try again later on, and I bet your outcome will be differentSmiley Happy

Hang in there, and heads up!! Gardening is hard, and getting debt down is hard too. Just keeping plugging along at it!!Smiley Happy
Message 8 of 15
KLEXH25
Valued Contributor

Re: PSECU Epic Fail :(

Ugh, I’m sorry. My successful 8 month gardening period was mostly spent AWAY from these forums lol. However no one wants to see you go! I really hope things come together for you and this will all just be a bad memory not long from now.


Message 9 of 15
Medic981
Valued Contributor

Re: PSECU Epic Fail :(

AJC, I can empathize with you. I have a torrid credit past and after the 2008 recession, I had a near minimum wage job for five years. I was finally able to get my stuff together with the help of family and go to nursing school. Now I have a well-paying job and I am learning to manage my credit because of folks like you here on the forums. I had to leave the forums for 7 months because the temptation to app was too great while reading about others successes. I have developed self-control and goals so I can again participate in the forums without "pulling the trigger". Hang in there, however, do what you need to do to get yourself where you want to be. 







Your FICO credit scores are not just numbers, it’s a skill.
Message 10 of 15
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.