cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Payment Preferences: Autopay or Manual?

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Payment Preferences: Autopay or Manual?

Just general curiosity among what you feel, along with some reasoning (however basic/complex it may be) for your preferences on payment method?

 

Primarily referring to payments that are more-of-less fixed amounts, such as rent/mtg, utilities, loans, insurance, etc.

 

I currently prefer manual payments, as I am still somewhat wary about relying upon the system to automatically pull payments each and every month. As I have acquired more services, I've started debating autopay but haven't been able to fully convince myself to switch.

Message 1 of 28
27 REPLIES 27
MakingProgress
Senior Contributor

Re: Payment Preferences: Autopay or Manual?


@Anonymous wrote:

Just general curiosity among what you feel, along with some reasoning (however basic/complex it may be) for your preferences on payment method?

 

Primarily referring to payments that are more-of-less fixed amounts, such as rent/mtg, utilities, loans, insurance, etc.

 

I currently prefer manual payments, as I am still somewhat wary about relying upon the system to automatically pull payments each and every month. As I have acquired more services, I've started debating autopay but haven't been able to fully convince myself to switch.


Mortgate = Autopay, we get I think a 1/4% reduction in APR.

Utilities = Autopay, they go onto cards where I get cash back

Insurance = Autopay, again on a card where I get cash back

Car loan = manual, no APR reduction and can't pay with a CC

 

Credit Cards = both, set up Autopay for minimum due just in case,  make manual payment prior to statement cut for full balance so that card will report 0 or a small balance if I have outstanding authoriztions. 

 

Edit: Acutally Electric bill is a manual pay because they want to charge me a fee GREATER than my cash back to use a CC. 

FICO 8 Starting Score

Current Scores


Garden Goal is All Reports Clean – Achieved 11/26/20
Message 2 of 28
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Payment Preferences: Autopay or Manual?


@MakingProgress wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

Just general curiosity among what you feel, along with some reasoning (however basic/complex it may be) for your preferences on payment method?

 

Primarily referring to payments that are more-of-less fixed amounts, such as rent/mtg, utilities, loans, insurance, etc.

 

I currently prefer manual payments, as I am still somewhat wary about relying upon the system to automatically pull payments each and every month. As I have acquired more services, I've started debating autopay but haven't been able to fully convince myself to switch.


Mortgate = Autopay, we get I think a 1/4% reduction in APR.

Utilities = Autopay, they go onto cards where I get cash back

Insurance = Autopay, again on a card where I get cash back

Car loan = manual, no APR reduction and can't pay with a CC

 

Credit Cards = both, set up Autopay for minimum due just in case,  make manual payment prior to statement cut for full balance so that card will report 0 or a small balance if I have outstanding authoriztions. 


@MakingProgress and are do it the exact same way.  Everything that can be put on CC is on Autopay on the CC.  CC's are on autopay of minimum just-in-case.  Mortgage, auto loan, and, in my case PG&E, are manual.

Message 3 of 28
Blackswizz750
Established Contributor

Re: Payment Preferences: Autopay or Manual?

I do both but watch everything to make sure it goes through or cards dont expire.

Message 4 of 28
MakingProgress
Senior Contributor

Re: Payment Preferences: Autopay or Manual?


@Blackswizz750 wrote:

I do both but watch everything to make sure it goes through or cards dont expire.


Agreed.  I would also add that I did NOT use autopay when my finances were out of control.   I know that for me when I was in financial difficulty I needed to control the day something processed or I might have been subject to overdraft or nsf fees. 

 

So now I use Autopay because I KNOW I have the funds available to let it process to my cards and then make the payment to the CC on time. 

FICO 8 Starting Score

Current Scores


Garden Goal is All Reports Clean – Achieved 11/26/20
Message 5 of 28
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Payment Preferences: Autopay or Manual?

Auto pay and watch to make sure the payments process. Also, where I can earn rewards I do.

Message 6 of 28
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Payment Preferences: Autopay or Manual?

I use autopay for fixed loan payments, like mortgages and car loans.  It ensures they get paid on time and the amount is always the same so there are no surprises.  I do direct draft from checking, no CCs for autopay.  For my HELOC payments, I chose a monthly amount and have an auto transfer from a checking account at the same bank.

 

For everything else, I do them manually.  That way I can examine the bill, check for errors, figure out how much and when it needs to be paid, and I schedule it through bill pay.  Depending on my financial state at the time, I may pay it ASAP or I may wait until my next paycheck hits, if it's before the due date.  For credit cards, I can decide if I can PIF, PTZ, before or after statement cut, or if I have to carry a balance.

 

 

 

Message 7 of 28
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Payment Preferences: Autopay or Manual?

Autopay everything except for homeowner association fee which is auto billpay from checking monthly.
Message 8 of 28
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Payment Preferences: Autopay or Manual?

Autopay everything whenever possible.  My CC's are set up to autopay the statement balance.  If a card is new I pay manually during the first two months it is on autopay as a backup.  Once it is clear that the autopay has fully kicked in I stop doing the manual payments.

Message 9 of 28
MakingProgress
Senior Contributor

Re: Payment Preferences: Autopay or Manual?


@Anonymous wrote:

I use autopay for fixed loan payments, like mortgages and car loans.  It ensures they get paid on time and the amount is always the same so there are no surprises.  I do direct draft from checking, no CCs for autopay.  For my HELOC payments, I chose a monthly amount and have an auto transfer from a checking account at the same bank.

 

For everything else, I do them manually.  That way I can examine the bill, check for errors, figure out how much and when it needs to be paid, and I schedule it through bill pay.  Depending on my financial state at the time, I may pay it ASAP or I may wait until my next paycheck hits, if it's before the due date.  For credit cards, I can decide if I can PIF, PTZ, before or after statement cut, or if I have to carry a balance.

 

 

 


Even though almost all my bills are on autopay, I still examine the bill and check for errors, that is the prudent thing to do. 

FICO 8 Starting Score

Current Scores


Garden Goal is All Reports Clean – Achieved 11/26/20
Message 10 of 28
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.