cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Get a 2nd secure card (from NFCU) or wait until scores improve?

tag
HereHaveSomeCredit
Valued Member

Get a 2nd secure card (from NFCU) or wait until scores improve?

Hi all! I'm newish to the forum. I am trying to decide if I should get a 2nd secured card or wait until my scores improve (see signature). I just got a Plat Secured w/ Cap1 ($400) that hasn't hit my credit report yet. I was just approved for a checking/savings with Navy Federal Credit Union and am trying to decide if I should apply for their secured card (I'm pre-approved). I've received mixed advice. I've been told I should have at least 2 open cards and I've also been told I should wait until my scores are 575+ to get the 2nd card. My signature has my credit details. I also have 5 lates (most recent is 2.5 years old), so a 2nd card would help me add more on time payments quicker.

 

1) Won't getting a 2nd card build my credit faster with on time payments reporting more often?

2) What would be the disadvantage of getting a 2nd card?

Starting scores 10/19/24

Scores 12/15/24

Capitol One Platinum Secured: $400. Credit Karma secured line of credit: $1000. Self Credit Builder Loan: $500
Baddies: 4 collections. 2 charged off cards reporting balances. 1 Inquiry.
Message 1 of 5
4 REPLIES 4
JoeRockhead
Community Leader
Super Contributor

Re: Get a 2nd secure card (from NFCU) or wait until scores improve?

I already gave my opinion on this, in this thread. Hopefully these two threads will be merged. 

Message 2 of 5
GZG
Senior Contributor

Re: Get a 2nd secure card (from NFCU) or wait until scores improve?


@HereHaveSomeCredit wrote:

Hi all! I'm newish to the forum. I am trying to decide if I should get a 2nd secured card or wait until my scores improve (see signature). I just got a Plat Secured w/ Cap1 ($400) that hasn't hit my credit report yet. I was just approved for a checking/savings with Navy Federal Credit Union and am trying to decide if I should apply for their secured card (I'm pre-approved). I've received mixed advice. I've been told I should have at least 2 open cards and I've also been told I should wait until my scores are 575+ to get the 2nd card. My signature has my credit details. I also have 5 lates (most recent is 2.5 years old), so a 2nd card would help me add more on time payments quicker.

 

1) Won't getting a 2nd card build my credit faster with on time payments reporting more often?

2) What would be the disadvantage of getting a 2nd card?


are you in a position to pay off your bad debt? 

 

if not, how close are you to paying/settling it off? 

 

Starting FICO 8:
Current FICO 8:



4/6, 4/12, 8/24 new accounts
Message 3 of 5
HereHaveSomeCredit
Valued Member

Re: Get a 2nd secure card (from NFCU) or wait until scores improve?


@GZG wrote:

@HereHaveSomeCredit wrote:

Hi all! I'm newish to the forum. I am trying to decide if I should get a 2nd secured card or wait until my scores improve (see signature). I just got a Plat Secured w/ Cap1 ($400) that hasn't hit my credit report yet. I was just approved for a checking/savings with Navy Federal Credit Union and am trying to decide if I should apply for their secured card (I'm pre-approved). I've received mixed advice. I've been told I should have at least 2 open cards and I've also been told I should wait until my scores are 575+ to get the 2nd card. My signature has my credit details. I also have 5 lates (most recent is 2.5 years old), so a 2nd card would help me add more on time payments quicker.

 

1) Won't getting a 2nd card build my credit faster with on time payments reporting more often?

2) What would be the disadvantage of getting a 2nd card?


are you in a position to pay off your bad debt? 

 

if not, how close are you to paying/settling it off? 

 


Yes, I will be paying all of the collections & 2x charge-offs this December, as I'll have a large influx of cash.

Starting scores 10/19/24

Scores 12/15/24

Capitol One Platinum Secured: $400. Credit Karma secured line of credit: $1000. Self Credit Builder Loan: $500
Baddies: 4 collections. 2 charged off cards reporting balances. 1 Inquiry.
Message 4 of 5
HereHaveSomeCredit
Valued Member

Re: Get a 2nd secure card (from NFCU) or wait until scores improve?

 


@JoeRockhead wrote:

I already gave my opinion on this, in this thread. Hopefully these two threads will be merged. 


Hi Joe! I appreciate your input very much. I'm hoping to get more opinions if possible. I created this thread since my previous one was about scoring, but I'm asking about the next rebuilding step here.

Starting scores 10/19/24

Scores 12/15/24

Capitol One Platinum Secured: $400. Credit Karma secured line of credit: $1000. Self Credit Builder Loan: $500
Baddies: 4 collections. 2 charged off cards reporting balances. 1 Inquiry.
Message 5 of 5
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.