cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Score drop after Cap1 combine

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Score drop after Cap1 combine

Combined 2 cap1 cards. One at 2 yr 2 months, 1500. One at 11 months, 2500. Rolled the older card into the newer because of the interest rate, it being visa, and I was told it didn't matter about aaoa when you close a card.
Something isn't right however because the older card I rolled in had a reported balance of 715/1500(obviously when I combined the cards the card was at 0)
Yesterday Exp was 674, with 10 total accounts(9 open, 1 closed) all of the accounts but the said Cap1, and the closed card were less than 2 years old.
Today Exp is 669, util dropped 3%, 10 total accounts, 8 open, 2 closed.
What the heck? AAoa definitely didn't change. Is it because of my total open accounts decreased by one?
Message 1 of 6
5 REPLIES 5
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Score drop after Cap1 combine

I received a 10pt drop for closing a secured card, prior to my 3rd card reporting.

 

Only thing I can muster with so little caffeine.

Message 2 of 6
Revelate
Moderator Emeritus

Re: Score drop after Cap1 combine


@Anonymous wrote:
Combined 2 cap1 cards. One at 2 yr 2 months, 1500. One at 11 months, 2500. Rolled the older card into the newer because of the interest rate, it being visa, and I was told it didn't matter about aaoa when you close a card.
Something isn't right however because the older card I rolled in had a reported balance of 715/1500(obviously when I combined the cards the card was at 0)
Yesterday Exp was 674, with 10 total accounts(9 open, 1 closed) all of the accounts but the said Cap1, and the closed card were less than 2 years old.
Today Exp is 669, util dropped 3%, 10 total accounts, 8 open, 2 closed.
What the heck? AAoa definitely didn't change. Is it because of my total open accounts decreased by one?

If it changed your math on number of cards reporting a balance, that's an easy 4-5 points.

 

Also the big question is how that tradeline now reports, tradeline changes can take 1-2 billing cycles to report correctly.

 

I wouldn't worry about it.

 




        
Message 3 of 6
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Score drop after Cap1 combine

It reports as closed and paid. Looks like it's reported correctly tbh. But so you think that's just a temporary thing?

I think there's something about like over half your cards carrying a balance hurting your score?
I went from 5/7 cards having some sort of balance,
To 4/6 cards.

Carrying a balance isn't a major deal as the cards have 0% interest and it's only about 15%. Cards will be paid down within 2 billing cycles to 0(even with constant use)

So you think this is literally a temporary thing and nothings actually worse? I mean that's what I'd like to hear of course.
Message 4 of 6
Revelate
Moderator Emeritus

Re: Score drop after Cap1 combine


@Anonymous wrote:
It reports as closed and paid. Looks like it's reported correctly tbh. But so you think that's just a temporary thing?

I think there's something about like over half your cards carrying a balance hurting your score?
I went from 5/7 cards having some sort of balance,
To 4/6 cards.

Carrying a balance isn't a major deal as the cards have 0% interest and it's only about 15%. Cards will be paid down within 2 billing cycles to 0(even with constant use)

So you think this is literally a temporary thing and nothings actually worse? I mean that's what I'd like to hear of course.

Temporary on some random vagary tied around utilization and reporting.  Again I wouldn't worry about it just focus on getting the debt paid and you'll likely more than recover.




        
Message 5 of 6
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Score drop after Cap1 combine


@Revelate wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:
It reports as closed and paid. Looks like it's reported correctly tbh. But so you think that's just a temporary thing?

I think there's something about like over half your cards carrying a balance hurting your score?
I went from 5/7 cards having some sort of balance,
To 4/6 cards.

Carrying a balance isn't a major deal as the cards have 0% interest and it's only about 15%. Cards will be paid down within 2 billing cycles to 0(even with constant use)

So you think this is literally a temporary thing and nothings actually worse? I mean that's what I'd like to hear of course.

Temporary on some random vagary tied around utilization and reporting.  Again I wouldn't worry about it just focus on getting the debt paid and you'll likely more than recover.


Agreed.

Message 6 of 6
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.