So I've had Scorewatch Since February and each time I've had a score increase or an alert I've seen evidence of it when I pull the experian report. Today I was told the my score went up 12 points (yay!) and I pulled the report again. Nothing had changed since my last report. Balances were the same, no inquiries had fallen off. Zilch, zip, nada! Has anyone seen score increases for no reason at all? I'm just curious.
Starting Score: EX: 658 TU: 646 EQ: 651
Sorry...should edit that I pulled Equifax per scorewatch not Experian 
I took your advice and purchased the 3 in 1 as well and pulled my Experian (no fico but at least I have an idea of who is reporting what) and they are all still reporting similar balances and the errant judgement is still on my record. Also in the last 5 days my EQ has jumped from about 633 to about 680 and my TU went from 627 to 659 and they aren't even reporting the actual balances that I've recently paid on my CC debt this month either. It's just very strange...I'm hoping to buy a new car at the end of the month and I want the scores as high as possible. I'm not trying to look a gifthorse in the mouth though. A minimum of 32 points in score raises over 10 days is NOT something I'm going to complain about
I wouldn't complain, either, but is this recent set of scores from a 3-in-1 service? If so, they're FAKO's, so they can't be compared (in terms of increase or decrease) with your FICO's. 
Keep up the good work, though, and the real scores will keep increasing as well.
eta: Equifax does have a 3-in-1 service that also comes with an EQ FICO, I believe, but the other two are FAKO's, and if you get EQ scores with subsequent pulls, they are also FAKO's. At any rate, I know that the 3-in-1 service won't keep updating your EQ FICO score.
This was confirmed by an Equifax CSR.
Keep up the good work, though, and the real scores will keep increasing as well.
eta: Equifax does have a 3-in-1 service that also comes with an EQ FICO, I believe, but the other two are FAKO's, and if you get EQ scores with subsequent pulls, they are also FAKO's. At any rate, I know that the 3-in-1 service won't keep updating your EQ FICO score.
This was confirmed by an Equifax CSR.
Score,
The new scores I got today were ones I purchased from myfico so they are legitimate. The original 3 in 1 was from Equifax because I wanted to check the actual report and see if anything was different from the myfico scorewatch service. I figured I had the extra money to spare...might as well make sure everything is on the up and up Either way I'm happy and glad that the scores have gone up over 40 points a piece since the end of February.