cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

What scores to believe?

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

What scores to believe?

good evening everyone

 

So now my question is whos scores to believe because they're all over..Heres what i did. I signed up for pretty much everything to see what my scores were

 

They are as  follows

 

Myfico website

Fico Scores

Equifax  526 

Trans     488

Experian 513

 

Experian website

Fico scores

Equifax  537

Trans     488

experian 513

 

Transunion website

621

 

Equifax website

648

 

Credit Karma website

Transunion 565

Equifax 629

 

Credit seame website

556 from experian I believe

 

from the quizzle website

equifax 629

 

 

So whos right and whos wrong. Im aware some are fico and some are vantage. but compairing like for like they are all over the place....

Message 1 of 11
10 REPLIES 10
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: What scores to believe?

it all depends on what models ur lender pull.  there is no "true" fico score....they are all FAKO IMO.  my best advice is to look thru your reports and figure out the baddies/ultilization. use scores service like myfico/CCT and have a baseline on where you stand.  

Message 2 of 11
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: What scores to believe?

Sorry for the newb question but what's CCT? I'm still working on removing things. Everything is paid but having a few collections, tax liens ( they are paid) and a BK from 07. I just now started rebuilding my credit. I thought that having no CC or debt was a good thing. So I have no credit history since 2012 LOL
Message 3 of 11
mikeymike1994
Established Member

Re: What scores to believe?

I would go with Myfico.com.  There are also various versions of your FICO score also depending what your purpose is. What the Myfico website displays is your Consumer Score (Version 8), but you also need to click on the tab for other FICO Versions.  If your goal is to qualify for a mortgage, then look at your FICO Mortgage scores.  If your goal is to finance a car, then look at you FICO Auto score.  If looking to get a credit card, then look at the FICO version for credit cards.

 

I recently applied for a mortgage and they had my scores pulled.  The scores that the mortgage company pulled were exactly as what the FICO Mortgage scores on Myfico.com said they were.  Hope this helps.

Message 4 of 11
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: What scores to believe?


@Anonymous wrote:
Sorry for the newb question but what's CCT? I'm still working on removing things. Everything is paid but having a few collections, tax liens ( they are paid) and a BK from 07. I just now started rebuilding my credit. I thought that having no CC or debt was a good thing. So I have no credit history since 2012 LOL

credit check total, there are threads on it and a lot of members have signd up for 14.95 a month.  it's better than myfico IMO

Message 5 of 11
mikeymike1994
Established Member

Re: What scores to believe?

Following up on my previous reply, the vast majority of creditors use some version of FICO.

Message 6 of 11
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: What scores to believe?


@Anonymous wrote:

good evening everyone

 

So now my question is whos scores to believe because they're all over..Heres what i did. I signed up for pretty much everything to see what my scores were

 

They are as  follows

 

Myfico website

Fico Scores

Equifax  526 

Trans     488

Experian 513

 

Experian website

Fico scores

Equifax  537

Trans     488

experian 513

 

Transunion website

621

 

Equifax website

648

 

Credit Karma website

Transunion 565

Equifax 629

 

Credit seame website

556 from experian I believe

 

from the quizzle website

equifax 629

 

 

So whos right and whos wrong. Im aware some are fico and some are vantage. but compairing like for like they are all over the place....


Quite simply - all of them and none of them. Each is correct based on its own rules. All are "wrong" compared to each other. The only score that really matters to any degree, is FICO scores, and there are a bunch of those - FICO 8, FICO 4, FICO 2, Beacon 5, Auto Enhanced, Bank Enhanced, etc, etc, etc....

 

OK, now having said that - what you should be concerned with, as richard pointed out, is not so much your scores, but rather you reports and your credit usage (UTI) and other credit related behaviors.

Message 7 of 11
mikeymike1994
Established Member

Re: What scores to believe?

I tend to disagree with the notion that there isn't necessarily a right or wrong score.  If most creditors (supposedly 90%) are looking at FICO scores, then FICO scores are what you need to concentrate on.  In addition, depending on what you are trying to do (buy a house, buy a car, get a credit card), you need to look at what your FICO score is for that particular version.  When you look at your Myfico.com report, there is a tab for Other FICO Versions and it will explain to you what those other FICO versions are used for (mortgage, auto, credit card, etc.).  You will be able to see your scores for each of those versions. I had a couple of mortgage companies pull my credit and the scores they pulled matched exactly what the FICO Mortgage version of my latest Myfico.com report said it was. 

Message 8 of 11
Revelate
Moderator Emeritus

Re: What scores to believe?


@mikeymike1994 wrote:

I tend to disagree with the notion that there isn't necessarily a right or wrong score.  If most creditors (supposedly 90%) are looking at FICO scores, then FICO scores are what you need to concentrate on.  In addition, depending on what you are trying to do (buy a house, buy a car, get a credit card), you need to look at what your FICO score is for that particular version.  When you look at your Myfico.com report, there is a tab for Other FICO Versions and it will explain to you what those other FICO versions are used for (mortgage, auto, credit card, etc.).  You will be able to see your scores for each of those versions. I had a couple of mortgage companies pull my credit and the scores they pulled matched exactly what the FICO Mortgage version of my latest Myfico.com report said it was. 


If you know what your lender is pulling sure, like in the mortgage world.  Problem is lenders could be using any FICO (and there's a bunch although there's probably only 18ish in common use out of the 50+ that one could possibly buy), or they could be using Vantage, or they could be using an internally developed score.

 

End of the day the report data matters, I track my scores for testing purposes with my overly geeky hobby but I really don't need to outside of that.

 




        
Message 9 of 11
taxi818
Super Contributor

Re: What scores to believe?


@Revelate wrote:

@mikeymike1994 wrote:

I tend to disagree with the notion that there isn't necessarily a right or wrong score.  If most creditors (supposedly 90%) are looking at FICO scores, then FICO scores are what you need to concentrate on.  In addition, depending on what you are trying to do (buy a house, buy a car, get a credit card), you need to look at what your FICO score is for that particular version.  When you look at your Myfico.com report, there is a tab for Other FICO Versions and it will explain to you what those other FICO versions are used for (mortgage, auto, credit card, etc.).  You will be able to see your scores for each of those versions. I had a couple of mortgage companies pull my credit and the scores they pulled matched exactly what the FICO Mortgage version of my latest Myfico.com report said it was. 


If you know what your lender is pulling sure, like in the mortgage world.  Problem is lenders could be using any FICO (and there's a bunch although there's probably only 18ish in common use out of the 50+ that one could possibly buy), or they could be using Vantage, or they could be using an internally developed score.

 

End of the day the report data matters, I track my scores for testing purposes with my overly geeky hobby but I really don't need to outside of that.

 


But note when dealing directly with banks and credit unions. I found that most of them will tell you which version they are pulling. If they dont know. This is where the credit pulls database comes in handy. type in name of lender. and your state. And you will see what they pull the majority of the time. Nothing is absolute. you will see something like Equifax. Auto enhanced for car loans. Then here you will know to look at all your equifax scores from my fico. and look specifically for the auto enhanced versions. Too bad those credit karma and credit sesame scores are worthless. But they are pricelss when looking at your report. Also. equifax direct is not fico unless you ask. it is some kind of plus score. Experian is not fico.

And transunion is some plus score. only reliable score from those is experian. The other two are just as bad as credit karma. good luck .

Message 10 of 11
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.