cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

I am livid!!!!!

tag
Save-n-Invest
Established Contributor

Re: I am livid!!!!!


@Anonymous wrote:

@ridgebackpilot wrote:

@Save-n-Invest wrote:

 

The last time I bought a car (the kid bugging me to buy a black car) the manufacturer was offering 0% financing. The kid brought a demo to the house for a test drive. We stopped along the way at Panera to look over his paperwork for the deal we struck on the phone. Of course he had financing info for the 0%. The numbers did not compute. I don't think they realize we can do math in our heads. Smiley Wink 

 

On the drive back he started with the nitrogen fill for tires and other nonsense. If I wanted a bunch of  useless nonsense I would have tuned into QVC. It was a cash deal, no foolishness just doc fees. I don't have any reason to make an opera of a car purchase. It's a personal preference not a standard for others. 


Just imagine: If you had taken their 0% financing deal and invested your cash in Tesla stock instead of a depreciating car, you'd have earned enough to be able to buy three or four cars by now! This principle is known as the "cost of capital" and it's a very real phenomenon.

 


Or Tesla could have done nothing. Maybe Apple won't skyrocket after the upcoming split. You never know. 


I've had a position in Apple for several years. If you like roller coasters I highly recommend it. I would not want to be in a situation that required me to unwind a portion on a monthly basis to make payments on anything. 

Message 41 of 63
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: I am livid!!!!!


@nycsimone wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:


We literally have people on this forum, a CREDIT forum, who so easily believe that the DEALERSHIP offers the best financing? The same dealerships at which you don't have any right to transparency in how much they're padding the rates they're quoting you? You just see "their" number... 

 

Manufacturers are ending 0% for 84 months. Credit unions are competitive again for well-qualified buyers, and have ALWAYS been the better bet for mid-high 600's. Doubly so for used vehicles. (Mod cut-Approaching flaming and is definitely non FSR-Not here please)


Dealerships just submit your info to verious financial institutions. If you get preapproved with your own bank (or credit union) and show them the rate you got they'll be able to match it (or beat it) 90% of the time. They most likely have a relationship established with local credit unions or banks that have a rate match program. So in most cases you're not going to lose out on the "rate".

 

What you also fail to take into consideration is the ability to get a better purchase price on a vehicle by financing thru the dealership. If the dealer is getting $1,000 from the bank for sending them your financing and they pass on $500 of that $1,000 to you then aren't you better off that way?

 

People that think "cash is king" or that "you're always better off getting your own financing" simply don't understand how the business works. Plain and simple. It's a package deal for the daelership and by limiting your options you're stepping over a dollar to pick up a penny.


I read this and I see someone who just can't admit that their information is incorrect and does not benefit the buyer to believe it to be true, ever. One must either have a vested interest in car dealerships having the upper hand (you own one, work at one, are related to or are friends with someone who does) or ego prevents you from admitting that the information you are insisting is true is a lie. 

 

Rate-matching is a REACTIVE tactic. If you had to bring in a competing offer, that means no, they were NOT going to give you the best rate. 

Message 42 of 63
Save-n-Invest
Established Contributor

Re: I am livid!!!!!

 

I would just like to mention to anyone financing for 72-84 months please ask yourself do you really need a car that costly? That's a long time to pay for a depreciating asset. Will it ever be worth the amount you owe on the loan? Low rates or 0% is tempting but do you want to be in hock that long for a ride? Letting someone put you into a payment is a fool's game. You are still obligated to pay off the loan.

 

Frequently I see threads started by a poster who asks if they will be able to roll thousands of dollars of negative equity into a new car loan.  That just makes the next car purchase more difficult. Life happens and we can never be certain when/if a new vehicle will be needed. Just think things through before signing anything. That car will still be there tomorrow. If someone else buys it another dealer has one waiting for you. 

 

FULL DISCLOSURE  I have no direct experience financing a car. I've never done it. I've bought luxury cars and paid for them at the point of sale. I saved for the purchase. My daily now is Walmart luxury IMO but considered luxury by the carmaker of course. Smiley Happy

 

If you are new to car buying do what is best for you. Don't be sold. Evaluate if you actually need the things (upsells) offered in the F&I office.  

 

I've known quite a few people who were uncomfortable without a car payment. Seriously. When they retired the debt on one car they almost got the shakes and ran right out and went back in hock for another. The people I know like that ended up with repos, forclosures or deed in lieu, bankrupcy and ordering from McDonald's $2 menu. They bought other things the didn't need with money that hadn't earned yet, too. Their fate was not cause exclusively by car purchases. 

 

If you need a certain type of vehicle for work that's different. I'm not referring to commuting,  pizza delivery or Uber. I mean a real job/business where your vehicle is primarily a business expense.

 

Good luck and happy motoring!

Message 43 of 63
coldfusion
Credit Mentor

Re: I am livid!!!!!


@Anonymous wrote:


I read this and I see someone who just can't admit that their information is incorrect and does not benefit the buyer to believe it to be true, ever. One must either have a vested interest in car dealerships having the upper hand (you own one, work at one, are related to or are friends with someone who does) or ego prevents you from admitting that the information you are insisting is true is a lie. 

 


Please be mindful that you've already had a post edited with mod comment in this thread for similar language.  I suggest that moving forward you tone your responses down another notch.  Thanks!

 

 

(7/2025)
FICO 8 (EX) 850 (TU) 850 (EQ) 850
FICO 9 (EX) 850 (TU) 850 (EQ) 850

$1M+ club

Artist formerly known as the_old_curmudgeon who was formerly known as coldfusion
Message 44 of 63
Gladius
Frequent Contributor

Re: I am livid!!!!!


@Save-n-Invest wrote:

 

I would just like to mention to anyone financing for 72-84 months please ask yourself do you really need a car that costly? That's a long time to pay for a depreciating asset. Will it ever be worth the amount you owe on the loan? Low rates or 0% is tempting but do you want to be in hock that long for a ride? Letting someone put you into a payment is a fool's game. You are still obligated to pay off the loan.

 

Frequently I see threads started by a poster who asks if they will be able to roll thousands of dollars of negative equity into a new car loan.  That just makes the next car purchase more difficult. Life happens and we can never be certain when/if a new vehicle will be needed. Just think things through before signing anything. That car will still be there tomorrow. If someone else buys it another dealer has one waiting for you. 

 

FULL DISCLOSURE  I have no direct experience financing a car. I've never done it. I've bought luxury cars and paid for them at the point of sale. I saved for the purchase. My daily now is Walmart luxury IMO but considered luxury by the carmaker of course. Smiley Happy

 

If you are new to car buying do what is best for you. Don't be sold. Evaluate if you actually need the things (upsells) offered in the F&I office.  

 

I've known quite a few people who were uncomfortable without a car payment. Seriously. When they retired the debt on one car they almost got the shakes and ran right out and went back in hock for another. The people I know like that ended up with repos, forclosures or deed in lieu, bankrupcy and ordering from McDonald's $2 menu. They bought other things the didn't need with money that hadn't earned yet, too. Their fate was not cause exclusively by car purchases. 

 

If you need a certain type of vehicle for work that's different. I'm not referring to commuting,  pizza delivery or Uber. I mean a real job/business where your vehicle is primarily a business expense.

 

Good luck and happy motoring!


Why should it matter if that person has to means to pay the note and "enjoys" the fruits of their labor?  

Message 45 of 63
Save-n-Invest
Established Contributor

Re: I am livid!!!!!

@Gladius ,

 

It's the buyers decision. I was simply offering another point of view. There seems to be a lot of selling on this thread. Acquiescing the dealer's wishes is not mandatory. 

 

Car dealer as financial advisor is a bridge too far. 

Message 46 of 63
CJ7
Frequent Contributor

Re: I am livid!!!!!


@ridgebackpilot wrote:

... But one dealership told me so many buyers misrepresent their creditworthiness that dealerships began pre-checking credit before they forward the file to their lenders. Why they can't do that with a SP is beyond me...

 


Especially since you aren't requesting credit from the dealership itself unless they're into self-lending.

I just got my app shotgunned at a dealership, 11 inquiries total including them and a Cap1 triple-pull.

After promising they wouldn't do that.  Alerts are popping up on my phone like mad.

They lost the sale over that.  I guess they figure that once you see all the damage that's been done,

you'll just suck it up and buy instead of have it all be for nothing.  They also seem to think the longer they can

keep you waiting inside the dealership, the more likely you'll go ahead and buy so those 6 hours waiting

weren't all for nothing.  Doesn't work with me.  I just grow more and more aggravated.

 


Message 47 of 63
Save-n-Invest
Established Contributor

Re: I am livid!!!!!


@CJ7 wrote:

@ridgebackpilot wrote:

... But one dealership told me so many buyers misrepresent their creditworthiness that dealerships began pre-checking credit before they forward the file to their lenders. Why they can't do that with a SP is beyond me...

 


Especially since you aren't requesting credit from the dealership itself unless they're into self-lending.

I just got my app shotgunned at a dealership, 11 inquiries total including them and a Cap1 triple-pull.

After promising they wouldn't do that.  Alerts are popping up on my phone like mad.

They lost the sale over that.  I guess they figure that once you see all the damage that's been done,

you'll just suck it up and buy instead of have it all be for nothing.  They also seem to think the longer they can

keep you waiting inside the dealership, the more likely you'll go ahead and buy so those 6 hours waiting

weren't all for nothing.  Doesn't work with me.  I just grow more and more aggravated.

 


Defintely agree on the time wasting resulting in aggravation. I will never understand why anyone thinks that annoying a prospect makes them want to do business with you. One of the mysteries of life. 

 

I was spoiled for many years doing business with the same salesman. I just lucked up when I went in to buy my first car. He was helpful cautioning me about my color choices in reference to resale value. I was young and didn't give a hoot about resale. He thought an astroroof would be a good idea. I didn't want it. When the car came in it had the roof. I loved it!!! Don't know if he bushed it a little or not but so glad the roof was there. I bought all my other cars with a sunroof except a convertible. 

 

I went to the same dealership to get another car. He was no  longer there. There was a younger salesman who was the reason I walked out. He was calling across the showroom "are you going to lose this deal for X dollars?" I responded "no, you are and kept walking".

 

I called around to a few dealers and found my guy. I just told him what I wanted on the phone. He located the car and called me back beating  the price of the goof who changed all the numbers from phone call one day until arriving the next day to finalize. 

 

My excellent salesman finally retired and left me out here to the young wise men who don't seem to know how to sell a car--to me anyway.

 

I'm just spoiled, I think. The long time guy was my only contact it the dealership. He arranged service and ran the middle on the rare occasion there was an issue with the service provided. Did he earn a comission on my deals? You betcha! He was worth his weigh in gold keeping me happy and not letting anyone waste my time.

 

They don't make 'em like that anymore. 

Message 48 of 63
nycsimone
Regular Contributor

Re: I am livid!!!!!


@Anonymous wrote:

@nycsimone wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:


We literally have people on this forum, a CREDIT forum, who so easily believe that the DEALERSHIP offers the best financing? The same dealerships at which you don't have any right to transparency in how much they're padding the rates they're quoting you? You just see "their" number... 

 

Manufacturers are ending 0% for 84 months. Credit unions are competitive again for well-qualified buyers, and have ALWAYS been the better bet for mid-high 600's. Doubly so for used vehicles. (Mod cut-Approaching flaming and is definitely non FSR-Not here please)


Dealerships just submit your info to verious financial institutions. If you get preapproved with your own bank (or credit union) and show them the rate you got they'll be able to match it (or beat it) 90% of the time. They most likely have a relationship established with local credit unions or banks that have a rate match program. So in most cases you're not going to lose out on the "rate".

 

What you also fail to take into consideration is the ability to get a better purchase price on a vehicle by financing thru the dealership. If the dealer is getting $1,000 from the bank for sending them your financing and they pass on $500 of that $1,000 to you then aren't you better off that way?

 

People that think "cash is king" or that "you're always better off getting your own financing" simply don't understand how the business works. Plain and simple. It's a package deal for the daelership and by limiting your options you're stepping over a dollar to pick up a penny.


I read this and I see someone who just can't admit that their information is incorrect and does not benefit the buyer to believe it to be true, ever. One must either have a vested interest in car dealerships having the upper hand (you own one, work at one, are related to or are friends with someone who does) or ego prevents you from admitting that the information you are insisting is true is a lie. 

 

Rate-matching is a REACTIVE tactic. If you had to bring in a competing offer, that means no, they were NOT going to give you the best rate. 


As I have said in a previous post, in the past I worked as a salesperson at a dealership. I no longer work at a car dealership. Even if I did, there's tenst of thousands of dealership...posting on this forum does absolutely nothing to help me.

 

What you fail to understand is that a car dealership is a business that is there to make money. Just how much money they make is based on the actual knowledge a buyer has.

 

The rate matching is provided by financial institutions, not the dealership. Many banks have this in place. A dealership is allowed by law to mark up an interest rate and get a bigger kickback from the financial institution but if you walk in with a rate that you're expecting to receive and a rate match is provided by the bank then there's obviously no markup unless that bank originally had an even lower rate.

 

I would suggest that you stop trying to be right and listen to the people that have actually worked in the field and know exactly how the process works instead of having personal vendettas against an entire industry.

Message 49 of 63
ridgebackpilot
Established Contributor

Re: I am livid!!!!!


@Save-n-Invest wrote:

 

FULL DISCLOSURE  I have no direct experience financing a car. I've never done it. I've bought luxury cars and paid for them at the point of sale. I saved for the purchase.


That explains your lack of understanding of manufacturer financing and incentives. You've always purchased cars the old-fashioned way. I respect that; in the 1950s, most people bought automobiles that way.


Today, however, manufacturers offer financing and incentives to sell cars that were unknown in past decades. Zero percent financing is the best example; it basically amounts to free money for those who qualify. As such, it's the biggest no-brainer in the credit universe. No credit card offers such rates except for short-term promotions.

 

With these kinds of subsidized incentives available to credit-worthy customers, it really makes no sense anymore to buy cars the old-fashioned way by paying cash. Even without zero-percent interest rates, few people today tie up capital in a depreciating asset like an automobile. Of course, if you don't feel comfortable carrying debt, then none of this matters and you're unlikely to take out a loan under any circumstances, whether it's financially advantageous or not.

 

Message 50 of 63
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.