cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Applied Via Refferal instead of through Prequal and got screwed (Discover)

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Applied Via Refferal instead of through Prequal and got screwed (Discover)

The title may be a bit harsh, but I feel like my fiancée got shafted by Discover.

She received about 18 mail offers over the last 10 months from them all offering an APR of 13.74-16% she applied via my refferal link expecting to get that apr, and today the card came in the mail, showing 21.99% APR!!!!

That's insane, her FICO is 720 which it shows is what they pulled. She has no credit card debt, the only debt she has is a mortgage loan with a little over 100k balance with no late or missed payments.

I just don't see why they would offer her 13.74-16% then approve her for 21.99% I mean that's a really high APR for someone with a 720 FICO Smiley Sad

What are your thoughts on this? They approved her with a nice SL (5k) so it's not like she barely got in, and she received mail offers for the last 10 months.
Message 1 of 10
9 REPLIES 9
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Applied Via Refferal instead of through Prequal and got screwed (Discover)

Maybe they thought her association with you makes her "high risk". :-)
Message 2 of 10
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Applied Via Refferal instead of through Prequal and got screwed (Discover)

She got the mailer because they had her info that she met certain criteria on a list with the CRAs.  It might have been a promotion to get her to apply and she needs a code.  Or something may have changed on her credit report from when they got the info on her.  I suggest she make a call and ask what the reason is.  I am a firm believer in not paying any interest so APRs means nothing to me but if she needs to carry a balance and that is why she got the card then calling is the best idea. 

Message 3 of 10
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Applied Via Refferal instead of through Prequal and got screwed (Discover)

Jemster - The only thing that changed since the mailers and applying is one more application for a business credit card from Chase, which the card doesn't show up on her personal reports so no lowered AAOA.

I have a feeling if she calls they'll say that it's because she didn't apply via the mailer, and that she's getting the refferal bonus.

It's not that she plans on carrying a balance, but if she does it's good to have a low APR in case. And it's just strange that they'd up it by over 5%.
Message 4 of 10
K-in-Boston
Epic Contributor

Re: Applied Via Refferal instead of through Prequal and got screwed (Discover)

Two quick things... she should have a year of 0% and once the year is up she can hit up chat and ask what APR offers are available for her. They will offer her another 0% and/or a permanent APR reduction.

Rant time. Assigned APRs make no sense to me sometimes. My Discover was about 15% on my approval with similar scores around 720 but a really low SL for me of $2500. NASA FCU gave me a $15k line with like 12% APR then gave my wife a $1k line with like 9.9% APR on the same card and same income with her scores like 50 points higher than mine at the time. Really wish I knew what was in the underwriters or computers' minds.
Message 5 of 10
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Applied Via Refferal instead of through Prequal and got screwed (Discover)


@Anonymous wrote:
Jemster - The only thing that changed since the mailers and applying is one more application for a business credit card from Chase, which the card doesn't show up on her personal reports so no lowered AAOA.

I have a feeling if she calls they'll say that it's because she didn't apply via the mailer, and that she's getting the refferal bonus.

It's not that she plans on carrying a balance, but if she does it's good to have a low APR in case. And it's just strange that they'd up it by over 5%.

If you got something out of referring her that is why the rate is higher.  This is what I see with Amex and Chase when they offer you a referral bonus the person you are referring is getting screwed out of part of their sign up bonus.  But a 16 percen or 22 percent are both things you shoudl never pay. If her intent is to carry a balance she should focus on cards with long introductry 0 percent rates  

Message 6 of 10
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Applied Via Refferal instead of through Prequal and got screwed (Discover)

K-In-Boston -

Yeah I know, but the max permanent reduction they offer is 3%. So that would make it 18.99% which is still horrible for someone at 720 FICO.

I'm just wondering say she signed up with an 800 FICO through the refferal link does Discover automatically up that person's APR to make up the refferal $? Like would she have gotten the same APR (or only 1% lower) even with an 800? Makes you wonder.

Message 7 of 10
K-in-Boston
Epic Contributor

Re: Applied Via Refferal instead of through Prequal and got screwed (Discover)

18.99 would be on the higher end, but every 6 months that could come down another 3%, or she could just perpetually be in a state of 0% for 12 months offers, which is even better!  Trust me, I feel your frustration.  BOA trusts me with very high limits, but my APRs are in the 17-20% range.  Chase and Citi give me the lowest 12-16% offered for their cards but conservative limits.  Again, not trying to minimize your dissatisfaction with the APR, but Discover is not the card you typically get for low APRs (although it certainly can become a very low APR card over time by being consistent with asking for reductions every 6 months).  

 

Also, we know credit score alone isn't what determines APRs.  Wish we could all figure out the magic formulas for each lender!  At the same time I got my Citi card at 12.24% there were lots of people here being approved with higher APRs whose credit scores were 50-100 points higher than mine.

Message 8 of 10
fltireguy
Valued Contributor

Re: Applied Via Refferal instead of through Prequal and got screwed (Discover)

How many cards does she currently have? How may of yours is she an AU on? this may come into play as well..

NFCU $60.4k/PenFed $22.5k/Commerce $15K/53 $11K/Synovus $14K/BBT $11K/CapOne $12K/DCU $7.5K/BMO $7.5K/Chase $14.5k/Cabelas $10K/ and many many more!
Total CL $398600, plus car and RV loan.
Ooh. Ooh. Getting closer to that $500K mark!
Message 9 of 10
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Applied Via Refferal instead of through Prequal and got screwed (Discover)

She currently has 5 cards (oldest is 9 years).

She is an AU on 2 of her Dad's cards that were opened between 2000 and 2005, perfect history on those she was added probably 8-10 years ago onto them.

She's an AU on 0 of my cards or any other cards...that seems like a pretty good profile to me.
Message 10 of 10
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.