cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Cancel Amex 5th CC to open new card

tag
MyFault
Valued Contributor

Cancel Amex 5th CC to open new card

How long do i need to wait before cancelling an Amex Credit Card to make room for another card? I have 5 Amex CC right now, and i''ve just now cancelled my Amex Everyday, in favor of replacing it with the new Hilton Surpass for the SUB.

If i cancelled my Amex ED today, can i apply for the Surpass today, or wait 24 hours, or wait 30 days?







  |  
Message 1 of 13
12 REPLIES 12
WasteMgmt
Regular Contributor

Re: Cancel Amex 5th CC to open new card

I would probably cancel one of the cards and wait a full month for your accounts to update on their end then apply for a new card. 


CapitalOne Venture X, CapitalOne Quicksilver, Chase Sapphire Preferred, Chase Freedom OG, Chase Freedom OG, Amex BCE, Wells Fargo Autograph
Last application 5/2023
Message 2 of 13
GZG
Senior Contributor

Re: Cancel Amex 5th CC to open new card


@MyFault wrote:

How long do i need to wait before cancelling an Amex Credit Card to make room for another card? I have 5 Amex CC right now, and i''ve cancelled my Amex Everyday, in favor of replacing it with the new Hilton Surpass for the SUB.

If i cancelled my Delta Blue today, can i apply for the Surpass today, or wait 24 hours, or wait 30 days?


if you wanted to cancel the card and then apply and then call recon to get it manually reviewed and they should be able to push it through sooner than waiting for a monthly cycle 

https://youtu.be/bYWjFLXC2xs?si=syCVMVxdNNqXmBnQ&t=360 

 

video above showed it took them about a week?

 

there's also the risk that you're in pop-up jail (no bonuses) so you should be able to request an account be reopened after closure within 30 days if need be

Starting FICO 8:
Current FICO 8:



2/6, 2/12, 6/24 new accounts
Message 3 of 13
JoeRockhead
Senior Contributor

Re: Cancel Amex 5th CC to open new card

I didn' think the charge cards counted towards the 5 card limit. Am I mistaken about that? 

Message 4 of 13
GZG
Senior Contributor

Re: Cancel Amex 5th CC to open new card


@JoeRockhead wrote:

I didn' think the charge cards counted towards the 5 card limit. Am I mistaken about that? 


nope, you're right 

do you only have 4 'credit cards' currently, the others are the Gold and Platinum charge cards? @MyFault 

 

BBP, Amazon Business Prime, Bonvoy Business, Delta Blue? 

Starting FICO 8:
Current FICO 8:



2/6, 2/12, 6/24 new accounts
Message 5 of 13
MyFault
Valued Contributor

Re: Cancel Amex 5th CC to open new card


@JoeRockhead wrote:

I didn' think the charge cards counted towards the 5 card limit. Am I mistaken about that? 


Charge cards do not, however i have 5 Amex CC between business and personal accounts.







  |  
Message 6 of 13
MyFault
Valued Contributor

Re: Cancel Amex 5th CC to open new card


@GZG wrote:

@JoeRockhead wrote:

I didn' think the charge cards counted towards the 5 card limit. Am I mistaken about that? 


nope, you're right 

do you only have 4 'credit cards' currently, the others are the Gold and Platinum charge cards? @MyFault 

 

BBP, Amazon Business Prime, Bonvoy Business, Delta Blue? 


Correct. I just, a few hours ago, closed my Amex EveryDay CC.







  |  
Message 7 of 13
GZG
Senior Contributor

Re: Cancel Amex 5th CC to open new card


@MyFault wrote:

@GZG wrote:

@JoeRockhead wrote:

I didn' think the charge cards counted towards the 5 card limit. Am I mistaken about that? 


nope, you're right 

do you only have 4 'credit cards' currently, the others are the Gold and Platinum charge cards? @MyFault 

 

BBP, Amazon Business Prime, Bonvoy Business, Delta Blue? 


Correct. I just, a few hours ago, closed my Amex EveryDay CC.


people don't usually update the signature so quickly haha

yeah your choices are wait for the next Amex FICO score update in a month, and it should be long enough, or apply now, get the denial letter which you should be able to get through the online portal, and call in be like 'I canceled my card, please reconsider' and they'll manually review and offer an approval hopefully with the old CL of your last card or more 

Starting FICO 8:
Current FICO 8:



2/6, 2/12, 6/24 new accounts
Message 8 of 13
CreditCuriosity
Moderator Emeritus

Re: Cancel Amex 5th CC to open new card

Can apply that day or next day, but will need to recon unless you are one that are eligible for more than 5 revolvers.   When you call they will say cause of 5 revolvers just say you closed one and they will make the call to other dept and get it approved for you and will still get bonus etc assuming you didn't get pop-up while applying before the denial.

Message 9 of 13
MyFault
Valued Contributor

Re: Cancel Amex 5th CC to open new card


@GZG wrote:

@MyFault wrote:

@GZG wrote:

@JoeRockhead wrote:

I didn' think the charge cards counted towards the 5 card limit. Am I mistaken about that? 


nope, you're right 

do you only have 4 'credit cards' currently, the others are the Gold and Platinum charge cards? @MyFault 

 

BBP, Amazon Business Prime, Bonvoy Business, Delta Blue? 


Correct. I just, a few hours ago, closed my Amex EveryDay CC.


people don't usually update the signature so quickly haha

yeah your choices are wait for the next Amex FICO score update in a month, and it should be long enough, or apply now, get the denial letter which you should be able to get through the online portal, and call in be like 'I canceled my card, please reconsider' and they'll manually review and offer an approval hopefully with the old CL of your last card or more 


Sorry, i don't get on here as much as i used to as we have a little one now so i updated my signature while making the post lol.

 


@CreditCuriosity wrote:

Can apply that day or next day, but will need to recon unless you are one that are eligible for more than 5 revolvers.   When you call they will say cause of 5 revolvers just say you closed one and they will make the call to other dept and get it approved for you and will still get bonus etc assuming you didn't get pop-up while applying before the denial.


Yea, so i have no patience and tried to apply yesterday as it was already updated in my amex login that the card was closed. Unfortunately got the pop-up. Frustratingly, while i'm going after the card for the SUB, it's also a card i believe i'd keep open and use. I do put quite a bit of spend on my other amex cards so hopefully they'll let me out of pop up jail soon as i'd like to use the 170k points from the SUB on a stay in May of '24.

 

 







  |  
Message 10 of 13
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.