cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Considering a mini-spree, could use some advice

tag
Anonymalous
Valued Contributor

Considering a mini-spree, could use some advice

I spaced out all my applications in the past, but this time I'm considering a mini-spree. The goal is to thicken my file with some cards I want, and then let them age, while trying to maximize my chances/SLs by spreading the inquiries among the 3 bureaus. The goal is 3 cards, in order of importance:

  • VISA Signature from a local credit union (EQ)
  • Elan Max Cash Preferred (alternately, the U.S. Bank Cash+) (TU?)
  • Freedom Flex (alternately, the Custom Cash) (Chase is EX, Citi should be as well)

Background: I'm a clean file. I've switched to AZEO (util <2%), and my FICO 8s range from 747 to 764, while my FICO 9s have always been significantly higher. My main weakness is I'm a thin, young file. I only have 3 cards (+1 AU), with the oldest being 18 months old (the AU card is roughly 25 years old). Aside from the cards, my file's empty. My CLs are all over the place -- $0.3K, $24K+, and $7K+ (AU $2K). My existing cards are from Cap1, Navy Fed, and FNBO. No credit seeking (1 to 2 inquiries at each bureau, and my last card/inquiry was 9 months ago).

 

Specific questions:

 

Does it sound reasonable? I'd appreciate hearing about any concerns or best practices.

 

I'll be at 1/12 after a card I opened last November passes the 12 month mark. When does that happen? Can I just wait until 1 day past the anniversary, or do I have to wait until December 1st? I've seen credit monitoring systems that do it both ways, but I'm specifically interested in how Elan and/or U.S. Bank handles it.

 

Anything I should worry about when it comes adverse action? I'd prefer to avoid CLDs or closures.

Message 1 of 44
43 REPLIES 43
800wannabe420
Regular Contributor

Re: Considering a mini-spree, could use some advice


@Anonymalous wrote:

I spaced out all my applications in the past, but this time I'm considering a mini-spree. The goal is to thicken my file with some cards I want, and then let them age, while trying to maximize my chances/SLs by spreading the inquiries among the 3 bureaus. The goal is 3 cards, in order of importance:

  • VISA Signature from a local credit union (EQ)
  • Elan Max Cash Preferred (alternately, the U.S. Bank Cash+) (TU?)
  • Freedom Flex (alternately, the Custom Cash) (Chase is EX, Citi should be as well)

@Anonymalous 

FYI,  Citi pulled EQ for me in Texas.

Message 2 of 44
Anonymalous
Valued Contributor

Re: Considering a mini-spree, could use some advice


@800wannabe420 wrote:

@Anonymalous wrote:

I spaced out all my applications in the past, but this time I'm considering a mini-spree. The goal is to thicken my file with some cards I want, and then let them age, while trying to maximize my chances/SLs by spreading the inquiries among the 3 bureaus. The goal is 3 cards, in order of importance:

  • VISA Signature from a local credit union (EQ)
  • Elan Max Cash Preferred (alternately, the U.S. Bank Cash+) (TU?)
  • Freedom Flex (alternately, the Custom Cash) (Chase is EX, Citi should be as well)

@Anonymalous 

FYI,  Citi pulled EQ for me in Texas.


That must be nice, because not that many lenders seem to pull EQ. But based on the big thread, Citi will probably pull EX in my state:

https://ficoforums.myfico.com/t5/General-Credit-Topics/Which-Report-Will-They-Pull-Part-2/td-p/63797...

 

Message 3 of 44
uncredited
Frequent Contributor

Re: Considering a mini-spree, could use some advice

Someone tag me when were at page 45 of this thread. Smiley Wink

 

Seriously, though, interested in the age/wait question regarding the 6mo/12mo dates as my next similar megathread was going to feature that same question.

Message 4 of 44
Anonymalous
Valued Contributor

Re: Considering a mini-spree, could use some advice


@uncredited wrote:

Someone tag me when were at page 45 of this thread. Smiley Wink

 


I think I'll be lucky to get to page 2. Smiley LOL

Message 5 of 44
SouthJamaica
Mega Contributor

Re: Considering a mini-spree, could use some advice


@Anonymalous wrote:

I spaced out all my applications in the past, but this time I'm considering a mini-spree. The goal is to thicken my file with some cards I want, and then let them age, while trying to maximize my chances/SLs by spreading the inquiries among the 3 bureaus. The goal is 3 cards, in order of importance:

  • VISA Signature from a local credit union (EQ)
  • Elan Max Cash Preferred (alternately, the U.S. Bank Cash+) (TU?)
  • Freedom Flex (alternately, the Custom Cash) (Chase is EX, Citi should be as well)

Background: I'm a clean file. I've switched to AZEO (util <2%), and my FICO 8s range from 747 to 764, while my FICO 9s have always been significantly higher. My main weakness is I'm a thin, young file. I only have 3 cards (+1 AU), with the oldest being 18 months old (the AU card is roughly 25 years old). Aside from the cards, my file's empty. My CLs are all over the place -- $0.3K, $24K+, and $7K+ (AU $2K). My existing cards are from Cap1, Navy Fed, and FNBO. No credit seeking (1 to 2 inquiries at each bureau, and my last card/inquiry was 9 months ago).

 

Specific questions:

 

Does it sound reasonable? I'd appreciate hearing about any concerns or best practices.

 

I'll be at 1/12 after a card I opened last November passes the 12 month mark. When does that happen? Can I just wait until 1 day past the anniversary, or do I have to wait until December 1st? I've seen credit monitoring systems that do it both ways, but I'm specifically interested in how Elan and/or U.S. Bank handles it.

 

Anything I should worry about when it comes adverse action? I'd prefer to avoid CLDs or closures.


Concerns and best practices:

 

1. US Bank is considered especially sensitive to recent inquiries and new accounts, so you might want to apply for that first.

2. I think the "best practice" is to avoid sprees, and add cards gradually.

 

Adverse action:

 

Chase has been known to close accounts shortly after approving them, if they see there has been aggressive credit-seeking. Whether your 3-card spree would be enough to trip that wire, I do not know.


Total revolving limits 569520 (505320 reporting) FICO 8: EQ 689 TU 684 EX 673




Message 6 of 44
M_Smart007
Legendary Contributor

Re: Considering a mini-spree, could use some advice


@SouthJamaica wrote:


Concerns and best practices:

 

 

2. I think the "best practice" is to avoid sprees, and add cards gradually.

 

 


@SouthJamaica, Now you tell meSmiley Tongue

BTW ...great advice. I am not to sure about sprees in this economic environment.

Message 7 of 44
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Considering a mini-spree, could use some advice

What are u waiting for do it now Smiley Tongue

No AA on Chase after getting approved for 4 cards, in fact had a nice chat at the branch yesterday, no auto CLI though.

Message 8 of 44
SouthJamaica
Mega Contributor

Re: Considering a mini-spree, could use some advice


@M_Smart007 wrote:

@SouthJamaica wrote:


Concerns and best practices:

 

 

2. I think the "best practice" is to avoid sprees, and add cards gradually.

 

 


@SouthJamaica, Now you tell meSmiley Tongue

BTW ...great advice. I am not to sure about sprees in this economic environment.


Well @M_Smart007 I don't think that advice necessarily applies to you, as I believe the banks and credit unions have a special place in their hearts for you.


Total revolving limits 569520 (505320 reporting) FICO 8: EQ 689 TU 684 EX 673




Message 9 of 44
Anonymalous
Valued Contributor

Re: Considering a mini-spree, could use some advice


@SouthJamaica wrote:

@M_Smart007 wrote:

@SouthJamaica wrote:


Concerns and best practices:

 

 

2. I think the "best practice" is to avoid sprees, and add cards gradually.

 

 


@SouthJamaica, Now you tell meSmiley Tongue

BTW ...great advice. I am not to sure about sprees in this economic environment.


Well @M_Smart007 I don't think that advice necessarily applies to you, as I believe the banks and credit unions have a special place in their hearts for you.


They have a special place in their heart for @Anonymous as well, it's just smaller (SLs). Smiley LOL

Message 10 of 44
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.