cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Too soon for another Credit Card?

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Too soon for another Credit Card?

Good afternoon,

 

Currently I have 2 secured cards (BOA and OpenSky), both of which are exactly 2 months old.

 

I've used both and paid them off both before the closing dates - my question is - is it too soon to apply for another credit card?


I was thinking a store card (Target?), but if anyone has any recommendations that would be great.

 

As of today the only scores I've been able to see are my FAKO scores from CK.com (677 TU and 671 EQ - so far only the OpenSky card has been reported). I signed up for a free trail from IdentityGuard.com and my score was "Unrated".

 

Any help would be appreciated.

 

 

Thanks.

Message 1 of 18
17 REPLIES 17
TRC_WA
Senior Contributor

Re: Too soon for another Credit Card?

Yes it's too soon.

 

I'd wait till I had 6 months history.

FICO8 current as of : 4-6-25 EQ: 736 TU: 728 EX: 722
Hard INQs last 12 months: EQ: 0 | TU: 0 | EX: 0
Verizon Visa $8500 Amex Delta Reserve $10,000 Care Credit $18,000
NFCU CashRewards $7500 Apple Card $7000 Best Buy $8000 Amazon $5000
NFCU auto loan (2022 Ford Bronco Sport Badlands - Cactus Gray) 6.95%
NFCU motorcycle loan (2024 Harley Davidson Road Glide - Alpine Green & Chrome) 9.45%
Total CL: $64,000 --- Total CC UTI: 31% --- AAoA: 6.5 years --- Income: $200k
Last app: 4-6-24
Message 2 of 18
CYBERSAM
Senior Contributor

Re: Too soon for another Credit Card?

Try CapOne prequel site, you should be able to get something. Even CK is FAKO score but they are near the FICO score (most of the time + or - 50 points) ok maybe thats too much! But with CapOne you can get a card with over 600 FICO score, same as Walmart.

 

You can get some cards that includes some version of FICO, like Walmart (TU) or even opening a Saving account with DCU (EQ)

 

BTW: Stay away from Sub-prime cards, like the two that I have(CreditOne and FirstPremire) They don't grow, they are very expensive for little credit that they give you and they harm your credit as having extra inquiries and opening too many accounts, that could prevent you from getting future cards such as Chase or AMEX







                
Message 3 of 18
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Too soon for another Credit Card?

For better results, wait till 6 months.  Enough time to show payment and responsible use of any cards gives you a better chance of getting an approval so wait it out a bit.

Message 4 of 18
newhis
Valued Contributor

Re: Too soon for another Credit Card?

What's your plan or your goal?

 

My plan was to get good card and good limits. I started with 2 cards, waited 7 months, got another 2, waited a few months more then get another 2. Getting higher limits lower APR each time. 

 

Before my first 2 cards I tried Cap1 and they denied my request because I had no history, 15 month later they approved me with a 15K Venture @ 12.9%.

 

Some people try for several cards and then they got stuck at low limits high APR for a long time. My Freedom is at 22.9% and will never change, I didn't waited enough for it.

Message 5 of 18
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Too soon for another Credit Card?

My first suggestion is to let one of the cards report a balance, even if it is $10. Paying both cards in full before the statements cut doesn't help a whole lot. The scoring system sees zero usage and your scores will be lower. I lost almost 20 pts when I paid a balance too soon. As far as when to apply, it will vary by person. Some say do it in multiples so they grow together, some say start gradually.  I am building gradually.  I waited 4 months after my first credit and store card to get another cc. We are closing on our house in 2 weeks. I plan to apply for a couple cards after closing, which is 4 mo after 2nd credit card. If I get a toy starting limit, I will hold off until November which is my 12 month mark for my first card. Keep in mind that one scoring factor is age of accounts. Every new card will drop that age and affect scores. It will take a couple years to build up that part of scoring.

 

The hardest part of building credit is having the patience to let our accounts grow not only in limits but age. Patience is paying off because my scores have increased 75+ points. When I got that first approval, I wanted to keep applying. The only thing that stopped me is the thoughts of having 4 cards with a $500 limit. I would rather let 2 report a while and get a $3-5k+ limit for the next card.  Hang in there, it gets better!

Message 6 of 18
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Too soon for another Credit Card?


@newhis wrote:

What's your plan or your goal?

 

My plan was to get good card and good limits. I started with 2 cards, waited 7 months, got another 2, waited a few months more then get another 2. Getting higher limits lower APR each time. 

 

@Before my first 2 cards I tried Cap1 and they denied my request because I had no history, 15 month later they approved me with a 15K Venture @ 12.9%.

 

Some people try for several cards and then they got stuck at low limits high APR for a long time. My Freedom is at 22.9% and will never change, I didn't waited enough for it.


One of my goals is to obtain the best credit and credit history in order to be able to get a good home loan (not anytime soon), but I guess I'm being anxious because I feel like 2 cards isn't enough to build enough credit / credit history.

Message 7 of 18
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Too soon for another Credit Card?


@Anonymous wrote:

My first suggestion is to let one of the cards report a balance, even if it is $10. Paying both cards in full before the statements cut doesn't help a whole lot. The scoring system sees zero usage and your scores will be lower. I lost almost 20 pts when I paid a balance too soon. As far as when to apply, it will vary by person. Some say do it in multiples so they grow together, some say start gradually.  I am building gradually.  I waited 4 months after my first credit and store card to get another cc. We are closing on our house in 2 weeks. I plan to apply for a couple cards after closing, which is 4 mo after 2nd credit card. If I get a toy starting limit, I will hold off until November which is my 12 month mark for my first card. Keep in mind that one scoring factor is age of accounts. Every new card will drop that age and affect scores. It will take a couple years to build up that part of scoring.

 

The hardest part of building credit is having the patience to let our accounts grow not only in limits but age. Patience is paying off because my scores have increased 75+ points. When I got that first approval, I wanted to keep applying. The only thing that stopped me is the thoughts of having 4 cards with a $500 limit. I would rather let 2 report a while and get a $3-5k+ limit for the next card.  Hang in there, it gets better!


Carrying a balance for some reason feels...odd to me, I can't explain it. But I'll give it a try one month and see how it goes.

 

Thank you for the advice and good luck with your endeavors!

Message 8 of 18
newhis
Valued Contributor

Re: Too soon for another Credit Card?


@Anonymous wrote:

One of my goals is to obtain the best credit and credit history in order to be able to get a good home loan (not anytime soon), but I guess I'm being anxious because I feel like 2 cards isn't enough to build enough credit / credit history.


 My DW started from no score and 17 months later is over 750 TU Score. She started with 2 cards. I remember when she went to JCP (5 months) and they offered a card without a HP (I wasn't there), she got the store card with $400 limit. Of course they HP her and I was mad. At that time I didn't know that JCP can grow fast. Target can't, so don't go with Target. Less than a year later her JCP is $6,500 and it helps her util.

 

If your home loan is not soon, then calm down, work with 2 cards. After 7 months and 6 statements, visit the prequal sites for Citi, Amex and Cap1. Amex can grow fast 3X at activation then 3X 6 months later (up to). Cap1, if you show 1 year with good payments, they can approve you with Venture at 15k even if the best limit you have is 6k for few months. If you let 6 months pass by between apps and you only get 1 or 2 cards, you can get good limits and low APR. That's my, have a few great cards with good limits. I don't want to manage 15 cards. Maybe I even get some cards with good bonus.

 


@Anonymous wrote:

Carrying a balance for some reason feels...odd to me, I can't explain it. But I'll give it a try one month and see how it goes.

 

Thank you for the advice and good luck with your endeavors!


 I don't plan to carry balance to pay interest, maybe I carry balance with 0% cards, that's all. You said that you pay both your cards before statement cut, that will make them report $0 balance to the bureaus. When you start from 0 history I don't recomend doing this. I think is better to let the cards report some balance (always less than 30%) then PIF before due date (I do it 2-3 days before due date, just to make sure every payment clears at due date). This way you will pay $0 interest and use the cards they way they are designed: use the card, wait for statement, pay the statement before due date to ride the grace period and pay $0 interest.

 

My DW and I got a joint secured loan for $500 back in november. We pay a little over $40 a month. We are going to pay less than $10 in interest and I'm sure that helped my DW to jump over 750 6 months after. When the loan reported less than $250 her score jumped almost 15 points even with several cards reporting a low balance.

 

If you want to maximize your score, only let 1 card report less than 10% balance. I prefer doing this only when you are going to apply for something. The Score model has no memory. This way, the lenders can see that I use the cards, sometimes a few more than others (5% or bonus requirements). Some prefer to always let only 1 card report.

 

There is not a single path to great credit history, but the basics are the same. Always pay on time, don't use them above your means and with a little time, you will have the credit history that you want.

Message 9 of 18
GoldSorata
Established Contributor

Re: Too soon for another Credit Card?


@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

My first suggestion is to let one of the cards report a balance, even if it is $10. Paying both cards in full before the statements cut doesn't help a whole lot. The scoring system sees zero usage and your scores will be lower. I lost almost 20 pts when I paid a balance too soon. As far as when to apply, it will vary by person. Some say do it in multiples so they grow together, some say start gradually.  I am building gradually.  I waited 4 months after my first credit and store card to get another cc. We are closing on our house in 2 weeks. I plan to apply for a couple cards after closing, which is 4 mo after 2nd credit card. If I get a toy starting limit, I will hold off until November which is my 12 month mark for my first card. Keep in mind that one scoring factor is age of accounts. Every new card will drop that age and affect scores. It will take a couple years to build up that part of scoring.

 

The hardest part of building credit is having the patience to let our accounts grow not only in limits but age. Patience is paying off because my scores have increased 75+ points. When I got that first approval, I wanted to keep applying. The only thing that stopped me is the thoughts of having 4 cards with a $500 limit. I would rather let 2 report a while and get a $3-5k+ limit for the next card.  Hang in there, it gets better!


Carrying a balance for some reason feels...odd to me, I can't explain it. But I'll give it a try one month and see how it goes.

 

Thank you for the advice and good luck with your endeavors!


Figure out when you statement dates are. You can then let a small balance report on the statement and then pay it right off so you don't end up paying interest.

Message 10 of 18
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.