cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Canceling Discover secured card and applying for unsecured?

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Canceling Discover secured card and applying for unsecured?

I recently cleaned up my credit history and brought my score up to 727. Before I did that, I applied for several credit cards and got rejected by all except for a discover it secured card. I've only had it a month. I was just approved for an HSBC credit card, so I'd rather use that card to build my credit. I see that my credit report will show that the discover card is a secured card, which I would think reflects poorly on me. I know that the discover it secured card can graduate to unsecured after several months, but I could probably use my HSBC card and get my score up over 750 in a few months and apply for a discover unsecured card and get that sooner than if I wait for their graduation process. So is there any reason I shouldn't close out this secured card right now?
Message 1 of 4
3 REPLIES 3
aircobra
Regular Contributor

Re: Canceling Discover secured card and applying for unsecured?


@Anonymous wrote:
I recently cleaned up my credit history and brought my score up to 727. Before I did that, I applied for several credit cards and got rejected by all except for a discover it secured card. I've only had it a month. I was just approved for an HSBC credit card, so I'd rather use that card to build my credit. I see that my credit report will show that the discover card is a secured card, which I would think reflects poorly on me. I know that the discover it secured card can graduate to unsecured after several months, but I could probably use my HSBC card and get my score up over 750 in a few months and apply for a discover unsecured card and get that sooner than if I wait for their graduation process. So is there any reason I shouldn't close out this secured card right now?

Opening an account and then closing it soon after reflects more poorly than a secured card ever could (not that a secured card even reflects poorly). You've also taken an HP for it, so it makes little sense to close it. I also don't think Discover will let you open a new account (I know with a current open account, you have to wait a year for it to have been open before apping for another). And if that is the case, you're probably going to get it to graduate before a year if you use it responsibly.

Currently rebuilding:
1/18 -
7/19 -

Message 2 of 4
kerplunk
Frequent Contributor

Re: Canceling Discover secured card and applying for unsecured?

I wouldn't close the Discover card. Discover is a great company, and they will likely automatically convert it to a non-secured card in 6-8 months of having the card.

Message 3 of 4
howellco2
Frequent Contributor

Re: Canceling Discover secured card and applying for unsecured?

The secured card does not reflect poorly it would hurt your credit worse to close it

Any way I had the secured card 300 limit in 10 months was upgraded to unsecure and they bumped line up to 2k 6 months later with out asking I'm now at 5k

MAJOR BANK CARDS Amex BC 15k, Amex CM 1500, Amex Delta 1k, BB&T Travel 4500, BBVA 6900, CAP1QS 2600, Discover 3300, Marvel MC 6000, Wells Fargo CR 4500, Blispay 2k
CREDIT UNION CARDS DCU 2k , Robbins 10k, United1st 5k
STORE CARDS Amazon 10k, Home Depot 5k, PayPal 4k, Walmart 6k, Lowes 12k
Message 4 of 4
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.