No credit card required
Browse credit cards from a variety of issuers to see if there's a better card for you.
What would you use it for?
If you don't travel much, neither card make much sense.
If you don't travel much, get a 2% flat rate cash back card such as Citi Double Cash, Fidelity, PenFed Power Cash, Alliant, or PayPal. Augment that with a card that gives 3% on dining such as the Chase AARP or the NFCU Go Rewards. Take it a step further and get the Amex Blue Cash Everyday or the NFCU More Rewards for 3% on groceries. Forget about travel cards.
You can always just get one of the 2% cash back card, i.e., paypal cashback mastercard, or citi double cash.
If you are willing to spend a bit effort to manage card, pair the 2% card with 2 rotating 5% category cards, i.e., discover it and chase freedom.
Unless you are even more engaged in Point game, I would just stay away from Amex system, its all points game in there, and value isn't high if you don't use it on flight or hotels.
It would help if you let us know your current cards, what your scores are, and what your current spend is to make a solid recommendation. You said you don't travel much, so neither of those cards seem appropriate from the limited information provided.
Get citi Double cash, easy peasy, no hassle.