cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

SHould I close FP card?

tag
Sitori
Frequent Contributor

SHould I close FP card?

I was talked into getting a first premier card last July when at a credit repair company. It only has a $300 limit and I'm pretty sure it has a 75$ AF. I haven't used it in months and it has a zero balance reporting. I was leaving it open to help with my AAoA and UTL.

I have heard that when applying for new credit some people look at FP as a red flag. I will be applying for NFCU membership and a CC from them as well as care credit, in the next few weeks. If the FP is there will this negatively affect me?

I don't want to pay the AF again, so I will probably close it. But if it will HELP me obtain new credit then I will leave it open. But if it will hurt me then I will close it before I apply for the new credit.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EQ 701, TU 685, EX ?
Wallet:
Amazon store $2500(10/12), Cap1 $1500 (10/12), Discover $1700 (11/1/12).
Message 1 of 42
41 REPLIES 41
afbar1114
Valued Contributor

Re: SHould I close FP card?

What is your profile like? If you can close it do it. Leaving it open can hurt on a recon. But if its your only one try for a cap1 card and go from there
AMEX PRG; AMEX EveryDay $14,800; Freedom $6k; Sapphire $7k; IHG Select $5k; Discover $2,400; BofA Better Balance $9,100; Bank Americard $5,900; Citi DC $2,700; Citi Diamond $2,500; BestBuy $20,000; Amazon Prime $5k, United Club $15,000; Home Depot $20,000; Barclays $7,500

Total Credit Limits: $122,650
Message 2 of 42
09Lexie
Moderator Emerita

Re: SHould I close FP card?

IMO, close it and make sure it's closed. You have other cc's now and it's done its job.
Message 3 of 42
NonSufficientFunds
Frequent Contributor

Re: SHould I close FP card?


@Sitori wrote:
I was talked into getting a first premier card last July when at a credit repair company. It only has a $300 limit and I'm pretty sure it has a 75$ AF. I haven't used it in months and it has a zero balance reporting. I was leaving it open to help with my AAoA and UTL.

I have heard that when applying for new credit some people look at FP as a red flag. I will be applying for NFCU membership and a CC from them as well as care credit, in the next few weeks. If the FP is there will this negatively affect me?

I don't want to pay the AF again, so I will probably close it. But if it will HELP me obtain new credit then I will leave it open. But if it will hurt me then I will close it before I apply for the new credit.

It looks like you have a couple other decent trade lines with respectable limits - and those accounts will age soon enough.

 

Just the $75-AF alone, would already put you very close to 30% utilization on the $300 limit. 

 

I would call them and ask them to either raise the limit (by a lot), or waive the annual fee.

 

Otherwise, this card is probably not worth keeping - Let it go, and move on.  It's no longer serving you.

 

 

Message 4 of 42
Sitori
Frequent Contributor

Re: SHould I close FP card?

I have discover more $1700(asking for a CLI later this month at the 6th statement), amazon store $2200, and cap1 $1500.

Ok, so close it most likely? Should I close it before I apply for the NFCU or should I wait until after. Is it helping me at all by being my oldest account?

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EQ 701, TU 685, EX ?
Wallet:
Amazon store $2500(10/12), Cap1 $1500 (10/12), Discover $1700 (11/1/12).
Message 5 of 42
tattooedhusker
Established Contributor

Re: SHould I close FP card?

Close it and don't look back.

NFCU CashRewards $13.5k | AMEX BCE $15k | Lowes $17k | Sportsmanss guide $7.6k | Chase Freedom $1k | Discover IT $4.4k |
Walmart $8k | Gordman's $2950
Message 6 of 42
Sitori
Frequent Contributor

Re: SHould I close FP card?

I've only had my other cards since oct/nov of last year so that's why I was afraid of closing it. I guess 3-4 months doesn't really make that much of a difference lol

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EQ 701, TU 685, EX ?
Wallet:
Amazon store $2500(10/12), Cap1 $1500 (10/12), Discover $1700 (11/1/12).
Message 7 of 42
tattooedhusker
Established Contributor

Re: SHould I close FP card?


@Sitori wrote:
I've only had my other cards since oct/nov of last year so that's why I was afraid of closing it. I guess 3-4 months doesn't really make that much of a difference lol

It won't ding your AAoA to close it since it will still report for 10 years, and $300 isn't going to effect your UTIL all that much. I would close it, and move on. The fees are atrocious, and it has seemed to serve it's purpose.

NFCU CashRewards $13.5k | AMEX BCE $15k | Lowes $17k | Sportsmanss guide $7.6k | Chase Freedom $1k | Discover IT $4.4k |
Walmart $8k | Gordman's $2950
Message 8 of 42
dodfire
Valued Contributor

Re: SHould I close FP card?


@tattooedhusker wrote:

@Sitori wrote:
I've only had my other cards since oct/nov of last year so that's why I was afraid of closing it. I guess 3-4 months doesn't really make that much of a difference lol

It won't ding your AAoA to close it since it will still report for 10 years, and $300 isn't going to effect your UTIL all that much. I would close it, and move on. The fees are atrocious, and it has seemed to serve it's purpose.


+1

*8/10/13
Message 9 of 42
Sitori
Frequent Contributor

Re: SHould I close FP card?

Ok thanks.

Should I close it before apping for the new credit or after?

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EQ 701, TU 685, EX ?
Wallet:
Amazon store $2500(10/12), Cap1 $1500 (10/12), Discover $1700 (11/1/12).
Message 10 of 42
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.