Which Citi card to PC?

[NoMoreE46]

I am most likely going to cancel my AA Platinum Select card ($13300) as the AF has hit.

I was given this list of Eight No AF cards that are eligible to PC.   Eight is a lot to me.

I thought my situation would be a great topic to get guidance on from y'all in the Community.

I do have a $12,000 Custom Cash that was for just for groceries.  However, I upgraded to the Amex BCP that will replace the CCC on groceries. 

Which of these eight would you PC to and why? 

TIA

1) American Airline Miles +AAdvantage MileUp (410)

2) Cash Back Costco Anywhere Visa®  (520)

3) My Deals +Citi Diamond Pfd (257)

4) ThankYou Preferred (084)

5) Double Cash  (142)

6) AT&T Access Credit (457)

7) Custom Cash (416)

8) Rewards+ (408)

[NoHardLimits]

---

@NoMoreE46 wrote:

I am most likely going to cancel my AA Platinum Select card ($13300) as the AF has hit.

I was given this list of Eight No AF cards that are eligible to PC.   Eight is a lot to me.

I thought my situation would be a great topic to get guidance on from y'all in the Community.

I do have a $12,000 Custom Cash that was for just for groceries.  However, I upgraded to the Amex BCP that will replace the CCC on groceries. 

Which of these eight would you PC to and why? 

TIA

1) American Airline Miles +AAdvantage MileUp (410) easy way to keep AA miles alive (AA miles still have expiration dates)

2) Cash Back Costco Anywhere Visa®  (520) only if you already have a Costco membership and don't mind a product change dead end (can't product change away from a Costco card)

3) My Deals +Citi Diamond Pfd (257)

4) ThankYou Preferred (084) 

5) Double Cash  (142) if you don't already have another catch all card earning 2% or more

6) AT&T Access Credit (457)

7) Custom Cash (416) if you have another higher spend 5% category not already covered by your existing Custom Cash

8) Rewards+ (408) point roundup in 10 point increments and 10% points back at redemption

---

Comments in red above.

[ptatohed]

---

@NoMoreE46 wrote:

I am most likely going to cancel my AA Platinum Select card ($13300) as the AF has hit.

I was given this list of Eight No AF cards that are eligible to PC.   Eight is a lot to me.

I thought my situation would be a great topic to get guidance on from y'all in the Community.

I do have a $12,000 Custom Cash that was for just for groceries.  However, I upgraded to the Amex BCP that will replace the CCC on groceries. 

Which of these eight would you PC to and why? 

TIA

1) American Airline Miles +AAdvantage MileUp (410)

2) Cash Back Costco Anywhere Visa®  (520)

3) My Deals +Citi Diamond Pfd (257)

4) ThankYou Preferred (084)

5) Double Cash  (142)

6) AT&T Access Credit (457)

7) Custom Cash (416)

8) Rewards+ (408)

---

What do the numbers in parenthesis mean?

You can never have too many Custom Cashes!  

[Kforce]

---

@ptatohed wrote:

You can never have too many Custom Cashes!  

---

^^^^ This would also be my pick

[crystal626]

I love the flexibility of the Custom Cash.

[NoMoreE46]

Good oberservation  @ptatohed.

I am guessing these paranthesized numbers are the internal identifying codes for the cards.   I copied and pasted the list above from my chat session.  

BTW, I am including the interesting Header  that preceded the list of eight from the chat:

Available Products: * Full Pend method

+ 2 Step method_Immediate method

[unsungivy]

---

@NoMoreE46 wrote:

I am most likely going to cancel my AA Platinum Select card ($13300) as the AF has hit.

I was given this list of Eight No AF cards that are eligible to PC.   Eight is a lot to me.

I thought my situation would be a great topic to get guidance on from y'all in the Community.

I do have a $12,000 Custom Cash that was for just for groceries.  However, I upgraded to the Amex BCP that will replace the CCC on groceries. 

Which of these eight would you PC to and why? 

TIA

1) American Airline Miles +AAdvantage MileUp (410)

2) Cash Back Costco Anywhere Visa®  (520)

3) My Deals +Citi Diamond Pfd (257)

4) ThankYou Preferred (084)

5) Double Cash  (142)

6) AT&T Access Credit (457)

7) Custom Cash (416)

8) Rewards+ (408)

---

Uh, you do know that mathwise the CCC is a better Grocery card than the BCP, unless you have the AF waived ATM. 

Definitely another Custom Cash. 

[NoMoreE46]

Yes, thanks @unsungivy.  The AF for the first year is waived.

---

@unsungivy wrote:

---

---

Uh, you do know that mathwise the CCC is a better Grocery card than the BCP, unless you have the AF waived ATM. 

Definitely another Custom Cash. 

---

[ptatohed]

---

@unsungivy wrote:

---

@NoMoreE46 wrote:

I am most likely going to cancel my AA Platinum Select card ($13300) as the AF has hit.

I was given this list of Eight No AF cards that are eligible to PC.   Eight is a lot to me.

I thought my situation would be a great topic to get guidance on from y'all in the Community.

I do have a $12,000 Custom Cash that was for just for groceries.  However, I upgraded to the Amex BCP that will replace the CCC on groceries. 

Which of these eight would you PC to and why? 

TIA

1) American Airline Miles +AAdvantage MileUp (410)

2) Cash Back Costco Anywhere Visa®  (520)

3) My Deals +Citi Diamond Pfd (257)

4) ThankYou Preferred (084)

5) Double Cash  (142)

6) AT&T Access Credit (457)

7) Custom Cash (416)

8) Rewards+ (408)

---

Uh, you do know that mathwise the CCC is a better Grocery card than the BCP, unless you have the AF waived ATM. 

Definitely another Custom Cash. 

---

I was thinking the same thing but I've said it too many times so I bit my tongue.  But, yeah, no AF first year does make sense.  

[Kforce]

---

@ptatohed wrote:

---

I was thinking the same thing but I've said it too many times so I bit my tongue.  But, yeah, no AF first year does make sense.  

---

^^^^

Did the exact same thing.

Bit my tongue.