cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Conflicting messages

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Conflicting messages

ARGHH!!! I'm so frustrated. When I pulled my reports in Jan 2007, at least one of the things hurting my credit report was that I had no installment loans, since both of my car loans have been paid off for over 6 years, as have my college loans. So, when I went to get a new car in Jan 2008, I could have paid it in full, however, I figured that I'd put down $22K and finance $11,400K on a 24-month loan, simply to boost my credit score. What was the effect? EQ and EX are both dinging me for opening up a new account! Experian even says that it will hurt my score until at least 35% of the loan is paid off. I've made 3 payments and my balance is now $9K, however, nowhere in the report does it show the original loan amount. If they don't know what the original loan amount was for, how do they know when I'm 35% done? Are they basing it on a period of 24 months and will I be hurt until I'm 9 payments in? I'm disputing a few items, but my scores have changed as follows: TransUnion - Jan 2007 - 746 May 2008 - 785 (Up 39 points) Equifax - Jan 2007 - 755 May 2008 - 758 (Up 3 points) Experian - Jan 2007 - 759 May 2008 - 747 (Down 12 points)(They were the ones that said last year that "There is a lack of recent installment loan info reported" and that "Establishing a new loan might be a good long-term strategy" My balances to credit limits went from 11% in 2007 to less than 1% in 2008. I really would like to be in the "800 club", or at least to have all of my scores over 760, but I have only been able to get one of my scores to move! This whole thing just sucks!
Message 1 of 2
1 REPLY 1
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Conflicting messages

Your will always have a negative. Once you account reports 35%+ paid off it will give you another 3 reasons for negatvie. Once you get those knocked out it will give you another 3.

FICO will never say "you are perfect don't do anything". Eventually as your score increaes even doing what FICO says might net you another 4-5 points over course of a year.

Your installment loans should show the original loaned amount. If they don't it is a problem. It should be listed under "high credit" or something like that. All my installment loans, even my mortgage have the original loan amount. If your loan is not reporting the original amount then there is no way for FICO to calculate how much has been paid off.

Installment loans generally don't give large increase by paying them down (unlike revolving accounts). They simply improve your score slowly as month after month you should you are "responsible" = low risk by paying on time every time. getting a loan, turning around and paying it off won't do any good. Setup your loan on a payment plan and forget about it.
Message 2 of 2
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.