cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

What is the MyFico rabbit hole? Are we any better than other credit management sites?

tag
jeffery581
Established Contributor

Re: What is the MyFico rabbit hole? Are we any better than other credit management sites?

RE: 

Exactly! The zeal to teach and help is so strong that many here don't stop to ask themselves:

 

1. Am I sure that what I'm presenting as fact is really true?

2. Am I sure that, in giving advice, I understand the advisee's situation and priorities?

 

 

 

 

 

 

This is a message board. I would not take everything everybody says for gospel. But if there appears to be consensus about a question, might not be bad advise.

Capital One Quicksilver Visa | Capital One Quicksilver Matercard | Sony Visa | ebay Mastercard | Best Buy Visa| Shell Mastercard | CareCredit | Amazon Rewards Visa | Discover it | Lowes | Home Depot | Chase Freedom | Ebates Visa | TJMAX Platinum MasterCard | Stash Signature Visa | Hilton Amex | Bank of America Cash Rewards Visa | Bank of America Better Balance Rewards Visa | US Bank Cash Rewards | Blue Cash AMEX | IHG Rewards Club World Mastercard | Barclay Cash Foward World Mastercard | Bank of America Travel Rewards Visa | US Bank Cash 365 AMEX | Amex Everyday | Target | CITI Double Cash | WELLS FARGO PROPEL AMEX | Royal Carribean Visa | AARP REWARDS VISA | BEst Western Mastercard
Message 21 of 33
wasCB14
Super Contributor

Re: What is the MyFico rabbit hole? Are we any better than other credit management sites?


@jeffery581 wrote:

RE: 

Exactly! The zeal to teach and help is so strong that many here don't stop to ask themselves:

 

1. Am I sure that what I'm presenting as fact is really true?

2. Am I sure that, in giving advice, I understand the advisee's situation and priorities?

 

 

 

 

 

 

This is a message board. I would not take everything everybody says for gospel. But if there appears to be consensus about a question, might not be bad advise.


That would depend on the people forming the consensus. Uninformed people can reach a consensus quickly. Informed, detail-oriented people may take ages to work out the minutiae.

Personal spend: Amex Gold, Amex Schwab Plat., BofA PR+CCR(x2), Costco
Business use: Amex Bus. Plat., BBP, Lowes Amex AU, CFU AU
Perks: Delta Plat., United Explorer, IHG49, Hyatt, "Old SPG"
Mostly SD: Freedom Flex, Freedom, Arrival
Upgrade/Downgrade games: ED, BCE
SUB chasing: AA Platinum Select
Message 22 of 33
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: What is the MyFico rabbit hole? Are we any better than other credit management sites?

I will gladly take our myfico community over other similar communities out there. We help and encourage each other here and it's a great thing to see. Smiley Happy

Message 23 of 33
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: What is the MyFico rabbit hole? Are we any better than other credit management sites?


@AverageJoesCredit wrote:
Sounds to me someone got scorned and blames others. This site offers wonderful advice but at the end of the day, one has to either accept it or do what they feel is right. No one is FORCED to follow advice. Similar to when you see all these bad reviews for something, chances are its from people who werent doing things right and expect immediate satisfaction then go to gripe so no one else will give their business. sure it easy to follow the leader here but that can happen with any thing you follow. Smiley Happy

+1 AverageJoes Smiley Happy

Message 24 of 33
SouthJamaica
Mega Contributor

Re: What is the MyFico rabbit hole? Are we any better than other credit management sites?


@jeffery581 wrote:

Yes, We are better.

 

My fico score went from 534 to 739.

 

This website has helped me repair and build my credit.  

 

Good rewards on the money I spend.

 

I have seen no favoritism.

 

You ask for advice you get it.

 

You ask for opinions you get them.

 

You also have to use a little common sense.

 

Before I joined this website I did not know anything about credit. Now, I bet I could give accurate and correct advise on just about anything credit related. (toot toot)

 

 


+1


Total revolving limits 568220 (504020 reporting) FICO 8: EQ 689 TU 691 EX 682




Message 25 of 33
AverageJoesCredit
Legendary Contributor

Re: What is the MyFico rabbit hole? Are we any better than other credit management sites?

Only want to add i was not trying to insuate the person being quoted was in fact a person with bad credit rhat was scorned etc etc, i just equated it to like an example of how sometimes people have a negative experience and want everyone else to have a negative experience as well. I honestly dont even know who said person is as i do not read other credit forums and was just trying to give some positive vibes for the forum i love and respect.

Sure there will always be some overhyping or things said like they are gospel here but i just wanted to say that at the end of it all each one of us must decide how to take said advice or info imparted here. . Apologies if my original statement came out wrong. Smiley Happy
Message 26 of 33
Creditplz
Valued Contributor

Re: What is the MyFico rabbit hole? Are we any better than other credit management sites?

MyFico and the forums were my first stop to gain knowledge on credit, since then I have visited many sites and NONE have been as helpful as what we refer to as "the forums". Also what you quoted on someone said that people on here encourage others to apply for everything is hugely FALSE! I used to be that member that would apply for something multiple times a week (many people on here can confirm this Smiley Sad) but I learned from people urging me to stop applying and telling me what would happen (AR, account closures, etc..) to not do that.
Message 27 of 33
Themanwhocan
Senior Contributor

Re: What is the MyFico rabbit hole? Are we any better than other credit management sites?


@wasCB14 wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@jeffery581 wrote:

 

 

Before I joined this website I did not know anything about credit. Now, I bet I could give accurate and correct advise on just about anything credit related. (toot toot)

 

 


Really?  Well, maybe!   One of the "flaws" I have seen on this site (much more than say FT) is overly-confident advice, that is often distilled from posts that have repeated over the years, which may no longer be true, if they ever were.  These are things like "Bank X likes/hates thing Y [carrying a balance, doing BT, getting other cards etc]" 

 

That, and not so much YMMV as much as Your Need May Vary: while I want to get $25M in total CL, that might not be your goal, so me telling you to go for all the CLIs you can get might not be the right advice.

 

But maybe jeffery581 does have all the knowledge....


Exactly! The zeal to teach and help is so strong that many here don't stop to ask themselves:

 

1. Am I sure that what I'm presenting as fact is really true?

2. Am I sure that, in giving advice, I understand the advisee's situation and priorities?

 

Sometimes people like to go for FOTM cards, and sometimes we assume that people with similar cards have similar needs and finances.

 

I'm not worried about someone here trying to sell me something; I'm worried that they are speaking well beyond their expertise and that no one will correct them in a timely manner.

 

My comment about the "anonymous" source's excellent credit was relevant to establish that AJC was wrong in speculating that the source has bad credit, blames others, and is unhappy after following advice on this website.

 

I wasn't saying that credit-smart people always have high FICO scores, or that all people with high FICO scores know a lot about credit. Rebuilders can learn a lot, and people who just pay their bills on time can have excellent scores without any advanced knowledge.


Well, some people find it difficult to 'correct' someone, or to voice an opinion that said person might have done the wrong thing, etc. Such comments often result in dire warnings/reminders to be only friendly and respectful. So when someone posts about how they applied for a dozen new store cards, the people who want to state that they did the wrong thing and start a discussion, would risk a complaint of a personal attack if they said what they really thought about the situation. So all that gets posted are a dozen Congrats, instead of corrections/discussions that might help future readers that might otherwise be tempted to repeat the mistake.





TU-8: 804 EX-8: 805 EQ-8: 788 EX-98: 767 EQ-04: 752    
TU-9 Bankcard: 837 EQ-9: 823 EX-9 Bankcard: 837
Total $443,800
Message 28 of 33
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: What is the MyFico rabbit hole? Are we any better than other credit management sites?


@Themanwhocan wrote:

@wasCB14 wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@jeffery581 wrote:

 

 

Before I joined this website I did not know anything about credit. Now, I bet I could give accurate and correct advise on just about anything credit related. (toot toot)

 

 


Really?  Well, maybe!   One of the "flaws" I have seen on this site (much more than say FT) is overly-confident advice, that is often distilled from posts that have repeated over the years, which may no longer be true, if they ever were.  These are things like "Bank X likes/hates thing Y [carrying a balance, doing BT, getting other cards etc]" 

 

That, and not so much YMMV as much as Your Need May Vary: while I want to get $25M in total CL, that might not be your goal, so me telling you to go for all the CLIs you can get might not be the right advice.

 

But maybe jeffery581 does have all the knowledge....


Exactly! The zeal to teach and help is so strong that many here don't stop to ask themselves:

 

1. Am I sure that what I'm presenting as fact is really true?

2. Am I sure that, in giving advice, I understand the advisee's situation and priorities?

 

Sometimes people like to go for FOTM cards, and sometimes we assume that people with similar cards have similar needs and finances.

 

I'm not worried about someone here trying to sell me something; I'm worried that they are speaking well beyond their expertise and that no one will correct them in a timely manner.

 

My comment about the "anonymous" source's excellent credit was relevant to establish that AJC was wrong in speculating that the source has bad credit, blames others, and is unhappy after following advice on this website.

 

I wasn't saying that credit-smart people always have high FICO scores, or that all people with high FICO scores know a lot about credit. Rebuilders can learn a lot, and people who just pay their bills on time can have excellent scores without any advanced knowledge.


Well, some people find it difficult to 'correct' someone, or to voice an opinion that said person might have done the wrong thing, etc. Such comments often result in dire warnings/reminders to be only friendly and respectful. So when someone posts about how they applied for a dozen new store cards, the people who want to state that they did the wrong thing and start a discussion, would risk a complaint of a personal attack if they said what they really thought about the situation. So all that gets posted are a dozen Congrats, instead of corrections/discussions that might help future readers that might otherwise be tempted to repeat the mistake.


While what you refer to has happened this site does allow others to express differing views as long as it's done in a friendly manner.  You can absolutely tell someone that posts 25 approvals from the SCT that they probably have made a mistake.  I certainly have done so.  We just dont want someone being told that they were an idiot for doing so.  It really comes down to delivery and as long as it's done in a polite way this site doesn't require everyone to be a lemming and say congrats everytime someone goes overboard in applying for credit.  There's no doubt that sometimes people do 'dumb' things when it comes to credit.  I'm not saying that you have been rude to posters but others have when their point could have been expressed better and delivered the same message.  If posters approach these types of siutations as a teaching moment instead of just expressing judgment then the replies will typically be better received and certainly stay within our FSR guidelines.

Message 29 of 33
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: What is the MyFico rabbit hole? Are we any better than other credit management sites?


@jeffery581 wrote:

re: 

Really?  Well, maybe!   One of the "flaws" I have seen on this site (much more than say FT) is overly-confident advice, that is often distilled from posts that have repeated over the years, which may no longer be true, if they ever were.  These are things like "Bank X likes/hates thing Y [carrying a balance, doing BT, getting other cards etc]" 

 

That, and not so much YMMV as much as Your Need May Vary: while I want to get $25M in total CL, that might not be your goal, so me telling you to go for all the CLIs you can get might not be the right advice.

 

But maybe jeffery581 does have all the knowledge...

 

 

 

 

 

WOW, what an attack!! Your examples of advise i might have given are totally irrational and a bad assumption. I am referring to things like low utilization, low if any inquires, types of credit ect. ect.. It is not that complicated. But you just insulted and attacked me. You assumed way to much. The key word in my post was bet. WOW.

 

 

 

 

 

I might ad to my original post. People like to attack other people on here, that's the only thing that is not couth.

 

 


Well. it wasn't meant as much as a personal attach, but to be clear your claim was:

 

Now, I bet I could give accurate and correct advise on just about anything credit related.

 

which, to me, is far bigger than "low utilization, low if any inquires, types of credit ect. ect."

 

 

Message 30 of 33
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.