cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

2 Years Old Inquiry Removed = Fico Score Increase 3 Points

tag
Brenke
Member

2 Years Old Inquiry Removed = Fico Score Increase 3 Points

Today one inquiry that was already over 2 years old was removed and my Ex Fico score increased by 3 points.

I always knew that an inquiry only affects the score for 1 year.

Then there's no other explanation since this is the only change to my credit file today. Nothing else happened to my credit file today, ABSOLUTELY NOTHING! Not even a payment reported, nothing...

See screenshot https://prnt.sc/vdU5exyCzOnT

If any of the more experienced members have another explanation I'll be glad to hear it. Thanks Smiley Happy 

Message 1 of 11
10 REPLIES 10
CH-7-Mission-Accomplished
Valued Contributor

Re: 2 Years Old Inquiry Removed = Fico Score Increase 3 Points


@Brenke wrote:

Today one inquiry that was already over 2 years old was removed and my Ex Fico score increased by 3 points.

I always knew that an inquiry only affects the score for 1 year.

Then there's no other explanation since this is the only change to my credit file today. Nothing else happened to my credit file today, ABSOLUTELY NOTHING! Not even a payment reported, nothing...

See screenshot https://prnt.sc/vdU5exyCzOnT

If any of the more experienced members have another explanation I'll be glad to hear it. Thanks Smiley Happy 


It wasn't the removal of that inquiry.   Something else happened in the background.   It could be anything from a minor change in utilization, to an old card dropping off/new card being added, or the general answer for when nobody knows what happened, "you got a change in scorecards."

After 12 months, inquiries have zero, absolutlely no effect on FICO scores on any model.   It would be like seeing a slight change in the spelling of your name on your credit report due to a typo and then attributing the score change to that typo change.   Completely unrelated.

 

When you get a score change it is not necessarily the thing that triggered the monitoring service to update.   It is the sum total of everything that has happened since that monitoring service last updated that particular score.

 

And frankly 3 points is just statstical noise.

Message 2 of 11
SouthJamaica
Mega Contributor

Re: 2 Years Old Inquiry Removed = Fico Score Increase 3 Points


@Brenke wrote:

Today one inquiry that was already over 2 years old was removed and my Ex Fico score increased by 3 points.

I always knew that an inquiry only affects the score for 1 year.

Then there's no other explanation since this is the only change to my credit file today. Nothing else happened to my credit file today, ABSOLUTELY NOTHING! Not even a payment reported, nothing...

See screenshot https://prnt.sc/vdU5exyCzOnT

If any of the more experienced members have another explanation I'll be glad to hear it. Thanks Smiley Happy 


You compared your credit report from today with your report from yesterday, and one inquiry was missing?  I thought that experian.com just removed the inquiries on the first of the month. Maybe I'm wrong.


Total revolving limits 568220 (504020 reporting) FICO 8: EQ 689 TU 691 EX 682




Message 3 of 11
AzCreditGuy
Valued Contributor

Re: 2 Years Old Inquiry Removed = Fico Score Increase 3 Points


@Brenke wrote:

Today one inquiry that was already over 2 years old was removed and my Ex Fico score increased by 3 points.

I always knew that an inquiry only affects the score for 1 year.

Then there's no other explanation since this is the only change to my credit file today. Nothing else happened to my credit file today, ABSOLUTELY NOTHING! Not even a payment reported, nothing...

See screenshot https://prnt.sc/vdU5exyCzOnT

If any of the more experienced members have another explanation I'll be glad to hear it. Thanks Smiley Happy 


I feel no one really knows, some say a year where the points come back. In my case that didnt happen, I experienced what you did as well a pt gain of 4 when an INQ fell off my report. 

Message 4 of 11
AzCreditGuy
Valued Contributor

Re: 2 Years Old Inquiry Removed = Fico Score Increase 3 Points


@CH-7-Mission-Accomplished wrote:

@Brenke wrote:

Today one inquiry that was already over 2 years old was removed and my Ex Fico score increased by 3 points.

I always knew that an inquiry only affects the score for 1 year.

Then there's no other explanation since this is the only change to my credit file today. Nothing else happened to my credit file today, ABSOLUTELY NOTHING! Not even a payment reported, nothing...

See screenshot https://prnt.sc/vdU5exyCzOnT

If any of the more experienced members have another explanation I'll be glad to hear it. Thanks Smiley Happy 


It wasn't the removal of that inquiry.   Something else happened in the background.   It could be anything from a minor change in utilization, to an old card dropping off/new card being added, or the general answer for when nobody knows what happened, "you got a change in scorecards."

After 12 months, inquiries have zero, absolutlely no effect on FICO scores on any model.   It would be like seeing a slight change in the spelling of your name on your credit report due to a typo and then attributing the score change to that typo change.   Completely unrelated.

 

When you get a score change it is not necessarily the thing that triggered the monitoring service to update.   It is the sum total of everything that has happened since that monitoring service last updated that particular score.

 

And frankly 3 points is just statstical noise.


I'll take 3 pts if I am at 797...so I could say I hit 800 Smiley LOL

Message 5 of 11
Brenke
Member

Re: 2 Years Old Inquiry Removed = Fico Score Increase 3 Points


@CH-7-Mission-Accomplished wrote:

@Brenke wrote:

Today one inquiry that was already over 2 years old was removed and my Ex Fico score increased by 3 points.

I always knew that an inquiry only affects the score for 1 year.

Then there's no other explanation since this is the only change to my credit file today. Nothing else happened to my credit file today, ABSOLUTELY NOTHING! Not even a payment reported, nothing...

See screenshot https://prnt.sc/vdU5exyCzOnT

If any of the more experienced members have another explanation I'll be glad to hear it. Thanks Smiley Happy 


It wasn't the removal of that inquiry.   Something else happened in the background.   It could be anything from a minor change in utilization, to an old card dropping off/new card being added, or the general answer for when nobody knows what happened, "you got a change in scorecards."

After 12 months, inquiries have zero, absolutlely no effect on FICO scores on any model.   It would be like seeing a slight change in the spelling of your name on your credit report due to a typo and then attributing the score change to that typo change.   Completely unrelated.

 

When you get a score change it is not necessarily the thing that triggered the monitoring service to update.   It is the sum total of everything that has happened since that monitoring service last updated that particular score.

 

And frankly 3 points is just statstical noise.


Then it should be the last one, ("the general answer for when nobody knows what happened, "you got a change in scorecards.")

 

Because I'm pretty much sure that nothing else happened since I checked my credit score last night and it was 775. 

Message 6 of 11
Brenke
Member

Re: 2 Years Old Inquiry Removed = Fico Score Increase 3 Points


@SouthJamaica wrote:

@Brenke wrote:

Today one inquiry that was already over 2 years old was removed and my Ex Fico score increased by 3 points.

I always knew that an inquiry only affects the score for 1 year.

Then there's no other explanation since this is the only change to my credit file today. Nothing else happened to my credit file today, ABSOLUTELY NOTHING! Not even a payment reported, nothing...

See screenshot https://prnt.sc/vdU5exyCzOnT

If any of the more experienced members have another explanation I'll be glad to hear it. Thanks Smiley Happy 


You compared your credit report from today with your report from yesterday, and one inquiry was missing?  I thought that experian.com just removed the inquiries on the first of the month. Maybe I'm wrong.


Yes, I checked it last night.

 

Actually, the inquiry's second birthday was April 23, but it got removed today May 7.

 

Usually, Ex removes my inquiries the first 10 days of the following month after 2 years.

Message 7 of 11
Brenke
Member

Re: 2 Years Old Inquiry Removed = Fico Score Increase 3 Points


@AzCreditGuy wrote:

@Brenke wrote:

Today one inquiry that was already over 2 years old was removed and my Ex Fico score increased by 3 points.

I always knew that an inquiry only affects the score for 1 year.

Then there's no other explanation since this is the only change to my credit file today. Nothing else happened to my credit file today, ABSOLUTELY NOTHING! Not even a payment reported, nothing...

See screenshot https://prnt.sc/vdU5exyCzOnT

If any of the more experienced members have another explanation I'll be glad to hear it. Thanks Smiley Happy 


I feel no one really knows, some say a year where the points come back. In my case that didnt happen, I experienced what you did as well a pt gain of 4 when an INQ fell off my report. 


Exactly, this is the second time that this happens to me, so go figure...

Message 8 of 11
OmarR
Established Contributor

Re: 2 Years Old Inquiry Removed = Fico Score Increase 3 Points


@SouthJamaica wrote:

@Brenke wrote:

Today one inquiry that was already over 2 years old was removed and my Ex Fico score increased by 3 points.

I always knew that an inquiry only affects the score for 1 year.

Then there's no other explanation since this is the only change to my credit file today. Nothing else happened to my credit file today, ABSOLUTELY NOTHING! Not even a payment reported, nothing...

See screenshot https://prnt.sc/vdU5exyCzOnT

If any of the more experienced members have another explanation I'll be glad to hear it. Thanks Smiley Happy 


You compared your credit report from today with your report from yesterday, and one inquiry was missing?  I thought that experian.com just removed the inquiries on the first of the month. Maybe I'm wrong.


Experian removes them on the first Sat of the following month, unless that Sat is the 1st on the calendar. Than it's the second Sat of that given month.

 EQ=850   TU=849     EX=850       0/24       UTIL=$1      AZEO

Message 9 of 11
babygirl1256
Senior Contributor

Re: 2 Years Old Inquiry Removed = Fico Score Increase 3 Points

@CH-7-Mission-Accomplished  . . . To me, I want every point that I can get . . . three points can make a difference between poor and fair . . . fair and good . . . good and very good and very good and excellent/exceptional. I'm still trying to get four points from Equifax so I can have 800 across all three CRAs.

 

Credit Score Chart.png

Starting FICO 8 Score in 06/2019: EQ-625, TU-649, EX-640
Current FICO 8 Score in 06/2021: EQ-796, TU-806, EX-812
Goal FICO 8 Score in 06/2022: EQ-825, TU-850, EX-850
Message 10 of 11
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.