cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

When to apply for next card?

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

When to apply for next card?

6 months ago I bought a house.  as soon as we closed on everything and prior to the mortgage reporting i took advantage of my score and applied and was approved for 2 cards (Citi double cash - 10k; BoA Rewards - 7k).  these both were 18 months no interest on balance transfers and i moved all debt onto those to avoid interest to try and pay down the remaining.  Both were maxed out after this.

 

In march, i took advantage of a 0% no interest for 18 months on my exsisting AMEX - 17k and moved the BoA debt there.  currently, my profile looks like this:

 

* AAoA - 19 years

* 100% on time payments across all accounts (revolving/installment)

*30 year mortgage @ 2.49% qith 460k remaning and 354 months remaining

*25K remanining in student loan debt

*13K remaining on auto loan, 36 months remaining at 4.99%

 

Hard Inqueries
Credit Plus Mortgage3/9/2020
Credit Plus Mortgage4/1/2020
Credit Plus Mortgage6/20/2020
Credit Plus Mortgage10/13/2020

 

AccountBalanceLimitRatioAPR
Walmart$0.00$1,450.000.0%22.90%
BoA$0.00$7,000.000.0%16.99%
Paypal$0.00$10,000.000.0%25.49%
Venture$0.00$7,750.000.0%17.99%
Amazon$0.00$10,000.000.0%27.49%
QuickSilver$0.00$11,000.000.0%22.99%
Citi$10,155.42$10,300.0098.6%16.99%
Amex$8,266.00$16,500.0050.1%16.99%
CareCredit$0.00$20,000.000.0%21.49%
Total$18,421.42$94,000.0019.6%21.65%

 

On credit karma, it shows me an "outstanding" odds to be approved for several cards.  is now a good time to apply, or should i wait until more drop off?

 

im showing FICO 8 scores of 740-760 

 

Goals: 

1) Pay down exsisting debt taking advantage of no interest periods.  I have 750-1000 per month to throw at this.

2)  get to AZEO.  i can achieve this with a balance transfer once i pay it down a bit further, and consolidate my debt from 2 cards to 1

3)  increase my available credit and reduce my overall utilization

4)  add another card with a very high limit, as future option for balance transger in/consolidate debt

 

appreciate any recommendations on timing/which card.  prefer 0 annual fee and good for transfer deals.  rewards not important for me.  MY concerns are that it is too soon to apply and that another "recently open account" would tank my score and get people balance chasing me or closing accounts,.

 

Message 1 of 14
13 REPLIES 13
Red1Blue
Super Contributor

Re: When to apply for next card?

Why do you need another credit card ?

Message 2 of 14
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: When to apply for next card?

to increase my overall available credit, dilute my credit utilization, provide additional avenues to continue paying 0 interest on exsisting debt by moving debt to different cards with 0% interest BT offers.

 

We may finance some home improvements, this would dilute the ratios if we were to throw 5-10k on a card.

 

Increase credit score for future second mortgage or HELOC

Message 3 of 14
KatSoDak
Frequent Contributor

Re: When to apply for next card?

Do you have just 12 months left on the Citi 0% balance transfer promo?  If so I would get that knocked down a bunch each month in case you can't find another BT card with a CL big enough to help.

 

I'm curious why you transferred all the BofA debt onto Amex instead of 50% of it and 50% of Citi.

 

It seems to me the safest way to use balance transfers is to pay a monthly balance high enough that you will clear the debt when the BT ends.  

 

Unless I misunderstand your situation, you need to pay $650 each month on BofA and as close to $500 as possible on Amex.  If you do this in 6 months you will be in a better situation to be granted another BT card.

 

By then there will likely be a couple from which you can select. I wouldn't do it now with the BofA card at 98%.

 

FICO 8:

EQ FICO 9 - 770
EX FICO 9 - 758

Citi (2) | Discover | HSBC | BOA | NFCU (2) | WF (2) | Simmons Bank | FNBO (2) | PENFED | BBVA | US Bank | Lowes | Care Credit | Home Depot AU
Message 4 of 14
FinStar
Moderator Emeritus

Re: When to apply for next card?

An item to keep in mind, based on what you shared in your op, Credit Karma suggesting any "odds" of approval are just as good as Miss Cleo foretelling your future.  In other words, not reliable.

 

The thing that may give some pause for any potential [new] lenders is your DTI and current utilization on individual accounts, namely Citi and AmEx.  While it's possible you *could* get approved, it's anyone's guess how much you'd be approved for -- all things considered.

 

Your op doesn't indicate specifically when you obtained the Citi and AmEx CCs, but if it's been 180+ days since you were approved, you could try and see if those 2 accounts may be eligible for a SP CLI.

 

Also, your SYNCB Amazon and PayPal accounts could qualify for a SP CLI if you haven't requested one in the past ~4 months or so.  You can do so by calling the Credit Solutions team.

 

Do you currently belong to any Credit Unions?

 

 

Message 5 of 14
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: When to apply for next card?

I didnt go 50-50 because i want as few cards with a balance as possible.  preferebly no more then 2 at a time.

 

BoA with a 7K limit was maxed, transgering it put me at 50% util with Amex instead so instead of:

 

Boa - maxed 6 months left

Citi - maxed 12 months left

 

its

 

AMEX - 50% 12 months left

Citi - maxed 12 months left

 

maybe not the right choice, but that was my logic

Message 6 of 14
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: When to apply for next card?

I dont belong to any credit unions.  

 

BoA and Citi hit 6 months in July, so soon.

 

I just got a CLI on paypal (7500 --> 10000) and a CLI on the amex prior to the transfer (11k -->16.5K)

 

Quicksilver last month as well (10k-> 11k)

 

Venture/Walmart/Amazon/Care credit all denied for CLI

 

 

Message 7 of 14
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: When to apply for next card?


@FinStar wrote:

An item to keep in mind, based on what you shared in your op, Credit Karma suggesting any "odds" of approval are just as good as Miss Cleo foretelling your future.  In other words, not reliable.

 

The thing that may give some pause for any potential [new] lenders is your DTI and current utilization on individual accounts, namely Citi and AmEx.  While it's possible you *could* get approved, it's anyone's guess how much you'd be approved for -- all things considered.

 

Your op doesn't indicate specifically when you obtained the Citi and AmEx CCs, but if it's been 180+ days since you were approved, you could try and see if those 2 accounts may be eligible for a SP CLI.

 

Also, your SYNCB Amazon and PayPal accounts could qualify for a SP CLI if you haven't requested one in the past ~4 months or so.  You can do so by calling the Credit Solutions team.

 

Do you currently belong to any Credit Unions?

 

 


Is there somewhere i can get pre-approval.  the hard inquiry would be worth it for a new LOC, but a denail would suck.  I did my last 2 apps based on credit karma, assuming their info was realtivaly accurate

Message 8 of 14
OmarGB9
Community Leader
Super Contributor

Re: When to apply for next card?


@Anonymous wrote:

@FinStar wrote:

An item to keep in mind, based on what you shared in your op, Credit Karma suggesting any "odds" of approval are just as good as Miss Cleo foretelling your future.  In other words, not reliable.

 

The thing that may give some pause for any potential [new] lenders is your DTI and current utilization on individual accounts, namely Citi and AmEx.  While it's possible you *could* get approved, it's anyone's guess how much you'd be approved for -- all things considered.

 

Your op doesn't indicate specifically when you obtained the Citi and AmEx CCs, but if it's been 180+ days since you were approved, you could try and see if those 2 accounts may be eligible for a SP CLI.

 

Also, your SYNCB Amazon and PayPal accounts could qualify for a SP CLI if you haven't requested one in the past ~4 months or so.  You can do so by calling the Credit Solutions team.

 

Do you currently belong to any Credit Unions?

 

 


Is there somewhere i can get pre-approval.  the hard inquiry would be worth it for a new LOC, but a denail would suck.  I did my last 2 apps based on credit karma, assuming their info was realtivaly accurate


Definitely never go by CK's approval odds. They're not real. They're pure marketing. You got lucky in this case.


Last App: 1/10/2023
Penfed Gold Visa Card

Currently rebuilding as of 04/11/2019.

Starting FICO 8 Scores:




Current FICO 8 scores:


Message 9 of 14
FinStar
Moderator Emeritus

Re: When to apply for next card?

If you want to see if there are any pre-qualification offers without impacting your credit (SP), you can try BB&T (if you're in their geo-lending area) or BBVA (at least before both of these institutions are fully integrated operations/product-wise).  BBVA->PNC, BB&T->TRUIST.

 

BB&T:

https://www.bbt.com/offers/checkOffers

 

BBVA - 2 cards:

ClearPoints - https://online.bbvausa.com/apply/credit-card-prequal?productid=0003

Rewards - https://online.bbvausa.com/apply/credit-card-prequal?productid=0005

 

Also, other SP pre-qualification options:

https://ficoforums.myfico.com/t5/General-Credit-Topics/Soft-pull-PREAPPROVALs-Updated-4-20-21/td-p/5...

Message 10 of 14
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.