cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Paid off instead of settled

tag
Society1
Regular Contributor

Paid off instead of settled

Hello so a debt collector I owed a balance to slashed it to 50%. I don't want it saying settled on my credit report I rather it say paid in full. Is there any chance of me & the collector coming to a agreement w/ "paid in full" while paying the 50% balance they offered?

Message 1 of 12
11 REPLIES 11
CYBERSAM
Senior Contributor

Re: Paid off instead of settled

First see if they would except pay for deletion! With 50% that is. Avoid given them money unless they remove the collection completely.

Also if you can provide more info on collection and the collector it would be helpful.







                
Message 2 of 12
thornback
Senior Contributor

Re: Paid off instead of settled


@CYBERSAM wrote:

First see if they would except pay for deletion! With 50% that is. Avoid given them money unless they remove the collection completely.

Also if you can provide more info on collection and the collector it would be helpful.


@Society1 Yes, try to offer a payment in exchange for deletion of the entire collection.

 

As for completely avoiding payment unless they agree to delete - I'd be bit cautious and consider the age of the debt before going that route.

 

If the collection only has a few months - maybe a year -  left of the 7 year reporting statute before it drops from your reports, then fine.  But, if it's due to remain longer than that you may want to consider paying it to avoid future updates.  Open collections that are being updated regularly, or even sporadically, will keep your scores suppressed- paying them so they stop updating will allow the negative to age and hurt less so your scores have a chance to recover a bit.  If the debt is still fairly new and/or still within the statute of limitations for debt collection in your state, you should absolutely pay or settle to avoid being sued. 

 

Which collection agency is it?

 

Personal Aphorism:"Forget What You Feel, Remember What You Deserve"
Starting FICO 8s | 09/2017: EX 641 ✦ EQ 634 ✦ TU 647
Current FICO 8s | 04/2022: EX 796 ✦ EQ 793 ✦ TU 790
Current FICO 9s | 04/2022: EX 790 ✦ EQ 788 ✦ TU 782
2022 Goal Score | 800s

My AAoA:
4.6 years not incl. AU / 4.9 years incl. AU
My AoOA: 9.2 years not incl. AU / 11.2 years incl. AU
Inquiries: EX 0/12 ✦ EQ 0/12 ✦ TU 0/12
Report Status: Clean
Garden Status:  


Without patience, we will learn less in life. We will see less. We will feel less. We will hear less. Ironically, rush and more usually mean less.
Message 3 of 12
sectionals
New Contributor

Re: Paid off instead of settled

@thornbackI paid off a charge-off (credit card, Best Buy/CBNA) in full and sent a goodwill letter as well but I never received any type of formal

feedback from them. Looked at my 3B and the payment status is different for all 3 reports (EQ 629 CO, TU 637 payment after CO, collection EX paid account/was a CO). Is there anyway I can get this account "deleted"? I keep getting mixed answers about this option and some of my buddies have said this is not even a thing. Will provide whatever details you or anyone else needs that would help you help me.

Rebuild (OCT 21) FICO 8: EX 578 FICO 9: EQ 516

Current FICO 8/9:
EQ 660/729
EX 670/714
TU 650/705

TCL: 34800
CCU: 3%

Message 4 of 12
sectionals
New Contributor

Re: Paid off instead of settled

EX score by the way is 651. Just saw I didn't include that.

Rebuild (OCT 21) FICO 8: EX 578 FICO 9: EQ 516

Current FICO 8/9:
EQ 660/729
EX 670/714
TU 650/705

TCL: 34800
CCU: 3%

Message 5 of 12
sectionals
New Contributor

Re: Paid off instead of settled

Any feedback you could provide @FireMedic1 would surely be appreciated as well. Just trying to better my financial health.

Rebuild (OCT 21) FICO 8: EX 578 FICO 9: EQ 516

Current FICO 8/9:
EQ 660/729
EX 670/714
TU 650/705

TCL: 34800
CCU: 3%

Message 6 of 12
sectionals
New Contributor

Re: Paid off instead of settled

Another question I've had is should the CCU be 10% on my cards or should it be less?

Rebuild (OCT 21) FICO 8: EX 578 FICO 9: EQ 516

Current FICO 8/9:
EQ 660/729
EX 670/714
TU 650/705

TCL: 34800
CCU: 3%

Message 7 of 12
sectionals
New Contributor

Re: Paid off instead of settled

MILSTAR 2389/CL 6500

NFCU Secured Card 664/CL 2250

CAP 1 PL Card 37/CL 1400

Credit One 0/CL 650

 

No installment loans

1 COLLECTION Progressive PIF

1 CO Best Buy/CBNA PIF

Rebuild (OCT 21) FICO 8: EX 578 FICO 9: EQ 516

Current FICO 8/9:
EQ 660/729
EX 670/714
TU 650/705

TCL: 34800
CCU: 3%

Message 8 of 12
FireMedic1
Community Leader
Mega Contributor

Re: Paid off instead of settled


@sectionals wrote:

MILSTAR 2389/CL 6500

NFCU Secured Card 664/CL 2250

CAP 1 PL Card 37/CL 1400

Credit One 0/CL 650

 

No installment loans

1 COLLECTION Progressive PIF

1 CO Best Buy/CBNA PIF


@sectionalsGW for CO's wont go anywhere. Kinda stuck with it. Nice its done and paid. No longer will it affect your aggregate util %'s and quit updating each month. It will fall 7yrs from the DoFD. Speaking of util %'s. Got to get those balances down. We say finances over FICO here. Pay down all that debt and leave 1 to report with <8,99%. Then PIF before the due date. Or AZEO as we say. Paying interest is $ you'll never see again. For instance your Cap1 card has a balance and you get cash back of 1.5%. But. Interest is 20%+ percent. Where'd your rewards go? Pay interest. We're a business with cards. We want profit like any other business. Pay interest for emergencies or unexpected incidents. It isnt free money. My fav saying is. If you cant pay it. Dont charge it. Make sense?


Message 9 of 12
sectionals
New Contributor

Re: Paid off instead of settled

Makes sense. Wish I would've cared about my credit more when I was I younger but you live and you learn. Anything else I can do on my end @FireMedic1 @to rebuild faster aside from paying down my debt. Did what you said and dropped one of my card balances down from 2389 to 1609. Will be down to 657 (9% CCU) in about a week. NFCU card will be down to 202 (10% CCU) as well and total revolving debt will be at 8.4%. Prequal for all of NFCU's cards. At least that's what they stated in an email and wanted to apply. 

Rebuild (OCT 21) FICO 8: EX 578 FICO 9: EQ 516

Current FICO 8/9:
EQ 660/729
EX 670/714
TU 650/705

TCL: 34800
CCU: 3%

Message 10 of 12
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.